Do You Have Mayweather In Your Top 100 ATG List?

[jrosales13]

to you theyre not....

but 6 div titles>>>>5

sweatpea and chavez sr>>>>>>>anything floyd has done

beating vargs>>>>.beating corrales

LOL @ 6 division>>>>5...Doesn't matter if they're paper titles eh?

Beating 2 very past their prime fighters>>>Anything Floyd has done? Really? Beating 2 old fighters over dominated the 130 pound division? Really?

Beating arguably a ruined Vargas over beating a prime undefeated Corrales? Really?

Yea, OK....

[badass316]

Obviously, he must be counting losses. But, if that's the case then how many journeyman who lost to a bunch of great fighters should we put on the top 100 ATG list?

You mean to tell me when you asses a fighter's resume you completely ignore the fights they've lost? I'm speechless here.

[IronDanHamza]

You honestly think PBF has a better resume than DLH? DLH has fought the best, win or lose, for pretty much his entire career. Resume's aren't only about wins, but the whole body of work.

Well, of course if you include all their fights then Oscar's is better but surely loss's can't count much to one's greatness?

I mean Chop Chop Corley lost to come great fighters. It doesn't make him any better than he is.

Compare achievements with achievments I struggle to see how Oscar is greater than Mayweather personally.

[IronDanHamza]

LOL @ 6 division>>>>5...Doesn't matter if they're paper titles eh?

Beating 2 very past their prime fighters>>>Anything Floyd has done? Really? Beating 2 old fighters over dominated the 130 pound division? Really?

Beating arguably a ruined Vargas over beating a prime undefeated Corrales? Really?

Yea, OK....

Baffling, right?

Dude doesn't turn off.

[Check]

Without a doubt he would be in the top 100. I think a better question would be is if he were in the top 50? Which I also believe he is in the top 50.

[jrosales13]

You mean to tell me when you asses a fighter's resume you completely ignore the fights they've lost? I'm speechless here.

Then where does Juan Laporte rank in the 100 ATG list? Surely he's closer to top 50 than top 100 right?

I mean he fought Salvador Sanchez, Julio Cesar Chavez, Kostya Tzsyu, Eusebio Pedroza, Wilfredo Gomez, Rocky Lordrige, John John Molina, Barry McGuigan, Ruben Castillo, Azumah Nelson amongst others.

I mean look at those names. By far greater than Oscar names.

So what, that he lost to damn near all of them right? That shouldn't matter right? So by all means he's closer to top 50 than top 100 correct?

[jrosales13]

Baffling, right?

Dude doesn't turn off.

It just gets ridiculous with some shit that is said on here.

[IronDanHamza]

Then where does Juan Laporte rank in the 100 ATG list? Surely he's closer to top 50 than top 100 right?

I mean he fought Salvador Sanchez, Julio Cesar Chavez, Kostya Tzsyu, Eusebio Pedroza, Wilfredo Gomez, Rocky Lordrige, John John Molina, Barry McGuigan, Ruben Castillo, Azumah Nelson amongst others.

I mean look at those names. By far greater than Oscar names.

So what, that he lost to damn near all of them right? That shouldn't matter right? So by all means he's closer to top 50 than top 100 correct?

That's an excellent example.

I was trying to think of a similar one but nothing wasn't sprining to mind.

[jrosales13]

But he isn't the end all be all in boxing history. If you think he is then I suggest visiting places other than this message board. I'm not saying he doesn't know his stuff, it's just that he isn't the end all be all. Maybe I'm taking it out of proportions a bit, but that's how he came off to me. If you hadn't noticed, this whole 100 ATG list is subjective, and not one person in this message board including him can probably formulate his own with just the knowledge that he has and not doing further research.

Oh by all means, no you're right, absolutely correct. I'm not the end all and be all in boxing history. And, there plenty of posters on this site that know way more than me.

However, I know enough about it's history and the great fighters to know. It's blasphemy to say Oscar is closer to top 50 ATG than top 100 ATG. Or to suggest that Oscar is close to Floyd.

[studentofthegam]

Considering Duran was a legit WW and 10x greater than either Hatton or Marquez...No, its not really the same, at all.

However, Floyds win over Hatton is a solid legit win in my eyes.

But comparing it to Leonards win over Duran is a little bit...silly.

Yeah it was a bad comparison. He was pretty established at WW. Hatton moved up before the Floyd fight but he's too small. However Khan and Bradley are ok to fight Floyd and its legit. One cant just wipe it away like it doesnt count. Marquez well I was big money for an easy night. It did send a sound message to the Pac camp. Then he whips the scariest guy at 147 in Mosley. He clips Pacman and we should be lookin top 5. If he then hangs around for Martinez GOAT.