Do You Have Mayweather In Your Top 100 ATG List?

[PacquiaoATG]

Mayweathet was in my top 1 ducker ATG. but in ATG list his in my top 40's.

[BigStereotype]

Fair enough we've all got our own definition of 'great', I can respect that, I think there are probably over 100 ATGs, and I estimate (just an estimate) that if I made a list Floyd would probably just make the top 100.

When doing all time rankings, do you do it purely off resume? Because yeah, then he's certainly not as high as I have him. I try to do it off a combination of how "good" I perceive the fighter to be as well as their resume. Basically, I won't take points away if you're not an explosive, aesthetically appealing fighter (Winky, B-hop) who beats everyone he fights, but I can bump you up in rankings if you convince me that your skills translate against anyone you fight.

[1believer]

Lol i bet most people here don't even have a top 20 ATG list, let alone a top 100 ATG list. But generally speaking it would be extremely difficult to name 100 fighters in history over Floyd.

[Mitch5]

I think a few years ago espn made a list and floyd was on that list. In my eyes floyd is in the top 100 of all time

[studentofthegam]

he's top 100, not top 50 at all.

3 of the above 6 wins were impressive, one was good, the others decent.

yeah but throw in a domination of Mosley and Marquez then you got top 50. We cant just act like the fights never happened. He also beat a strong DLH and crushed Hatton. If we give SRL props for beating Duran who moved up then Hatton and Marquez should count right?

[THe TRiNiTY]

Well, I don't have an official list. However, I can see him making the top 100 fighters of all time. Maybe in the 60-80 range or so.

He's a brilliant fighter when he turns it on. Great defense, solid power and blistering speed. He could also retire undefeated. While that would leave questions if it meant that he retired today, but he'd still have a solid resume and career.

[studentofthegam]

Mayweathet was in my top 1 ducker ATG. but in ATG list his in my top 40's.

Thats a big boy answer. Green K

[puga]

top 100?..yes...top 50?....not sure...but id put him right next to hoya!....

[jrosales13]

He's very easily top 100 ATG, That can't even be debated.

And, very well could be argued that he's top 50 ATG.

[jrosales13]

yeah but throw in a domination of Mosley and Marquez then you got top 50. We cant just act like the fights never happened. He also beat a strong DLH and crushed Hatton. If we give SRL props for beating Duran who moved up then Hatton and Marquez should count right?

,

wow...smh

Please study the game up some more.