Do You Have Mayweather In Your Top 100 ATG List?

[Canelo Phresh]

puga is cuda makes sense lol

[jrosales13]

Sure, can't argue that. Especially the sweet pea and Sturm fights. Although I think he did enough to beat Ike.




My point went over your head again. Not once did I mention or even hinted that "losses outweigh wins." I said that losses are part of the boxer's body of work. PBF doesn't have nearly enough great wins to offset anything DLH has done in my opinion. And judging from their whole body of work, DLH has the better resume. Heck even if you just went with wins DLH still outdoes him. Chavez and Sweet Pea are better than anything PBF can claim.

OMFG, can't be ****ing serious with that bull****. Did any of you guys watch boxing in the 90's?

Actually he does, I thought we went over this already. He was 4-5 against HOF opposition. DeJesus doesn't count since he wasn't listed in IBHOF. So he isn't 6-6 like you mentioned.




Then that's your opinion, which I highly disagree with and will continue to do so whenever this subject (and its little nuances) is brought up lol

He's in the WBHOF, still HOF.

[ShoguNinja]

I may not like Floyds P@nk A$$ but as a true Boxing Fan, he is in my Top 75-100 because of his "Defensive Skills." But Pacquiao *****s him in achievement and will "beat the crap out of him" if they ever fight because Pacquiao is a southpaw with speed, power, stamina, skills, smarts and relentless fearsome aggression that gives Floydie nightmares thats why he doesn't want to fight Packy.

[puga]

So wait, you're saying Whitaker wasn't showing decline then proceed to say he struggled with Roger Mayweather? Who isn't even close to being a HOF fighter? A little confusing.

But on a real. Whitaker did NOT struggle with Roger Mayweather.....he damn near dominated.

LMAO @ 'almost ktfo' how on God's green earth was he almost 'ktfo'??????? Roger caught him and dropped him, in which Whitaker got up and was absolutely fine, and was NEVER in trouble or hurt again.

Watch fights, please.

damn you just exposed youself....the roger fight was long before swetpea had made a name for himself homeboy... ..please practice what you preach and do your research....

[IronDanHamza]

Sure, can't argue that. Especially the sweet pea and Sturm fights. Although I think he did enough to beat Ike.




My point went over your head again. Not once did I mention or even hinted that "losses outweigh wins." I said that losses are part of the boxer's body of work. PBF doesn't have nearly enough great wins to offset anything DLH has done in my opinion. And judging from their whole body of work, DLH has the better resume. Heck even if you just went with wins DLH still outdoes him. Chavez and Sweet Pea are better than anything PBF can claim.




Actually he does, I thought we went over this already. He was 4-5 against HOF opposition. DeJesus doesn't count since he wasn't listed in IBHOF. So he isn't 6-6 like you mentioned.




Then that's your opinion, which I highly disagree with and will continue to do so whenever this subject (and its little nuances) is brought up lol

Body of work I can certainly agree with.

But wins, I can't see how Oscar is higher than Mayweather. But I guess that's just my opinion at the end of the day.

[puga]

And, there you have it folks....

Baracuda, you're a fucking moron...STFU you clown.

This is my response to your dumbass...

...this is how jro says , i give up......like always...you cant handle the truth son.....not even you visiting my profile every week has help you debate me.....lol...you think i did'nt know?....

[IronDanHamza]

damn you just exposed youself....the roger fight was long before swetpea had made a name for himself homeboy... ..please practice what you preach and do your research....

Are you really that dense?

I didn't say the Roger Mayweather fight was the reason he was on the slide you ****ing imbecile.

I said you claimed Whitaker wasn't done then proceeding to claim he looked like **** against a fighter who frakly is dead average. Which if you don't know, is an open contradiction.

One in which you were talking utter nonsense about.

He showed he was on the slide by his performances vS. Riviera and Hurtado. ANYONE could see that. But evidently, you weren't around to see it.

[IronDanHamza]

...this is how jro says , i give up......like always...you cant handle the truth son.....not even you visiting my profile every week has help you debate me.....lol...you think i did'nt know?....

No, It's actually because you're an utter moron.

I mean, to suggest Whitaker even remotely struggled with Roger Mayweather is one thing. But to then suggest he almost 'KTFO' is quite possibly the most idiotic thing I have ever read on these boards.

And shows anyone who actually saw those fights that you clearly, hadn't and still havn't seen it.

You can't have seen that fight and possibly have that assesment. It's impossible.

[puga]

Are you really that dense?

I didn't say the Roger Mayweather fight was the reason he was on the slide you ****ing imbecile.

I said you claimed Whitaker wasn't done then proceeding to claim he looked like **** against a fighter who frakly is dead average. Which if you don't know, is an open contradiction.

One in which you were talking utter nonsense about.

He showed he was on the slide by his performances vS. Riviera and Hurtado. ANYONE could see that. But evidently, you weren't around to see it.

lol......excuses....you implied in your post that the roger fight was later on in sweetpea's carreer which was not the case....that my friend proves you arejust ****ridding jro's high horse argument but really did'nt know much about it....then you have the nerve to tell someone to watch fights?....lol

[puga]

No, It's actually because you're an utter moron.

I mean, to suggest Whitaker even remotely struggled with Roger Mayweather is one thing. But to then suggest he almost 'KTFO' is quite possibly the most idiotic thing I have ever read on these boards.

And shows anyone who actually saw those fights that you clearly, hadn't and still havn't seen it.

You can't have seen that fight and possibly have that assesment. It's impossible.

for someone who reaaly has'nt seen the fight and gives his 2 cents about it, you sure have the nerve...