Floyd certainly dont deserve no1, with his 4 fights in 5 year policies. Bradley should be ranked higher than Floyd as he has a win over Pac which is better than anything floyd has ever done.
Announcement
Collapse
No announcement yet.
How is Pac still ranked P4P #1 on BS?
Collapse
-
-
-
Originally posted by Big Dunn View PostI thought manny beat bradley?
Thats why Bradley wont be p4pn01 though, no one would be comfortable putting Bradley no1, when their eyes saw Pac beat Bradley.
Comment
-
Originally posted by hugh grant View PostPac did beat Bradley, but i said Bradley has on paper a win over Pac, which is better than anything Floyd has ever done.
Thats why Bradley wont be p4pn01 though, no one would be comfortable putting Bradley no1, when their eyes saw Pac beat Bradley.
Unless of course we go with what really happened rather than on paper. which means manny beat tim, but lost to JMM, who floyd thouroughly destroyed, means floyd is still ahead of manny and should be #1
Comment
-
Originally posted by Big Dunn View Postok. well on paper, manny lost to tim and on paper floyd hasn't lost. so, using your logic, floyd is still ahead of manny and should be #1.
Unless of course we go with what really happened rather than on paper. which means manny beat tim, but lost to JMM, who floyd thouroughly destroyed, means floyd is still ahead of manny and should be #1
YOu cant have floyd no1 on the basis of being unbeaten. Theres too many unbeaten boxers in this world.
Comment
-
Originally posted by hugh grant View PostWell considering Floyd came in over weight and bloated JMM up as well as only fights 4 times in 5 years that is not good enough to be no1 p4p. Pac beat everyone else better than Floyd so that puts Pac above Floyd.
YOu cant have floyd no1 on the basis of being unbeaten. Theres too many unbeaten boxers in this world.
manny also bloated JMM up, but didn't win by as large a margin.
There are alot of undefeated fighters. Manny isn't one of them.
Comment
-
Originally posted by whirlwind View PostFor the last 5 years up to this very moment this what you got from Floyd.
Floyd 2008-2012
past prime Cotto
sucker punched Ortiz
past prime Mosley
weight cheated Marquez
In this is what you got from Pacquiao in the same years.
Pacquiao 2008-2012
Pac beat Bradley in one sided but got robbed
Pac beat Marquez fairly, no weight cheating, fight can go either way
past prime Mosley
17 lbs weight advantage Margarito
one sided decision prime Clottey
tko12 prime Cotto
tko Hatton in rd2 and retired him for good
made him quit and retired Oscar for good
Diaz
beat the younger prime Marquez in a close fight
Comment
-
Originally posted by hugh grant View PostWell considering Floyd came in over weight and bloated JMM up as well as only fights 4 times in 5 years that is not good enough to be no1 p4p. Pac beat everyone else better than Floyd so that puts Pac above Floyd.
YOu cant have floyd no1 on the basis of being unbeaten. Theres too many unbeaten boxers in this world.
lol, how many of them are in the top 10 pound for pound since more than a decade, how many of them have been champions in 5 weight class, how many of them has been lineal champ in 3 classes, how many of them won 8 titles ?
Comment
-
Originally posted by Big Dunn View Postso losses don't matter, it's only number of fights. ok. so floyd, should still be #1 because they are both at ww but floyd has won more above 147 than manny has.
manny also bloated JMM up, but didn't win by as large a margin.There are alot of undefeated fighters. Manny isn't one of them.
Did pac come in over weight limit....no? And common opponents its still only JMM Floyd supposedly did better, with the bloating JMM controversy though that wont go away, and Pac not only fights more and wins more than Floyd, to top it off hebeats people better than floyd as well.Last edited by hugh grant; 07-26-2012, 03:16 PM.
Comment
-
Originally posted by hugh grant View PostWell if you dont fight much you are not going to get beat are ya? FLoyd shouldnt have been no1 anyway when Pac was beating morales and barrera and JMM, but people get things wrong it happens sometimes.
Did pac come in over weight limit....no? And common opponents its still only JMM Floyd supposedly did better, with the bloating JMM controversy though that wont go away, and Pac fights more as well as well as beats people better than Floyd.
I cant believe how ******ed you can be
Comment
Comment