Max Kellerman calls Pacquiao the greatest fighter ever! Do you agree?

[KILLA RIGHT]

top 75 maybe 50

[Turok2]

Who said that? Are you mentally ******ed? Serious question? Are you legally mentally ******ed? I would really like to know this

And, BTW the same goes for Floyd. You do know Floyd has had a career before the Oscar fight right?



No he's not. Yes, he's top 3, at best #2. But, not the GOAT.



More importantly than who is when, you dumb fuck



You want to know what Duran or SRL would do that version of Maragrito? You're acting like that was the same Marg of 2004. JUST STFU, that was a washed up Marg. That win means ****. Duran already beat way bigger and better guys than that version of Marg like Barkley and Castro.



More importantly than who is when you dumb fuck.



Duran win over a prime Leonard ****s on anything Pac has ever done. And, that was a smallish borderline past prime Duran.



Only F'ing idiots like you have Pac over Duran.

Don't fucking respond to me about historic topics if you only started watching boxing a couple years ago. My tolerance for idiots like you is running low. It's obvious that you have no idea WTF you're talking about. Just STFU, and read so you can learn some stuff.

[IMG]//www.threadbombing.com/data/media/22/*****_applause.gif[/IMG]

[JDezi4]

Top 15, maybe top 10, and would certainly give most of the fighters that r ahead of him very tough fights (and could even beat quite a few of them)....

That said, HELL NO he's not the best ever...

I never agree with Max Kellerman anyway

[puga]

pac was already labeled as the greatest southpaw of all time 5 fights ago....i think he's defnitely top 10 atg....maybe top 5 even.....

[mathed]

Thoughts?

Maybe the greatest fighter that Kellerman has ever seen live. Robinson would disagree though for sure...as would about 20 other boxers. I'll say that Pac is definitely one of the most exciting and brave fighters I have ever seen. Pac catches a lot of flak for Arum's decisions though...I'm sure Pac would take on whoever is in front of him. Old Bob knows how to make a buck and he knows how to negotiate but he thinks he can hold the boxing world hostage- he does far more harm than good.

[Phil Ivey]

Manny's the best of our time but not the greatest fighter ever imo.. but when he retires and decades past by I think his ATG status will be elevated and people would be talking about him like they talk about Leonard, Hagler, Duran, Hearns today.

[RSBonos]

From 01 to early 08 he was one of the better boxers in the sport, but greatest of all time, I don't think so. He's hasn't exactly been beating guys that Leonard, Robinson, Hagler, Hearns, Duran wouldn't wipe the floor with. Shane Mosley is the best fighter Pacquiao will fight since Marquez but it is too late though, Mosley is too old and as much as I hope this will be a good fight, I think Mosley showed what he had left against Mayweather and Mora, which was not much.

You can't sit there and tell yourself, Leonard can't walk through Pacquiao's resume. You can't sit there and think Pacquiao would walk through Leonard's resume of Duran 2x, Hagler, and Hearns[at 160 no catchweight]. You just can't. If Manny is the GOAT, then Leonard, Ali, and Robinson are gods.

You don't count Pac's Cotto win as significant?

He's not the greatest of all time but a few more wins and if he beats Mayweather then he is top 10 all time or as low as 5. IMO he is already around the #10 mark

How can you compare Leonard who was a natural WW with Manny who came up from flyweight?

The greatest indicator of his success are the amount of people discrediting him.

I used to know a guy who back in the day was certain that Penny Hardaway was greater then Jordan. People like that will always be around.

[STRUGG]

not the GOAT......but definitely/hands down/ without a question................better than floyd b1tchweather.......................

[mathed]

You don't count Pac's Cotto win as significant?

He's not the greatest of all time but a few more wins and if he beats Mayweather then he is top 10 all time or as low as 5. IMO he is already around the #10 mark

How can you compare Leonard who was a natural WW with Manny who came up from flyweight?

The greatest indicator of his success are the amount of people discrediting him.

I used to know a guy who back in the day was certain that Penny Hardaway was greater then Jordan. People like that will always be around.

TRUTH........................

[neoz]

If Floyd has the balls to fight Manny.
And Manny beats Floyd, I would rate Manny GOAT.