In what WeightClass & Percentage of PBF career will "YOU" judge FLOYD MAYWEATHER???

[Horus]

Nobody knew, nor gave a **** about Floyd until he moved up to welter, so I say WW.

You my friend are a casual fan thats why..

[JAB5239]

I was always under the illusion that a fighters career should be judged by what he DID and DID NOT do during his prime.

[andrewcuff]

if you want to make that argument go ahead...lol
Floyd did his undefeated while becoming Undisputed champion in 3 divisions and Fighter of the year a combined 10 times..With fighting for 11 years with being a Offical World Champion 10 of them...

i got stats for pages...

You've stated this before. Please explain where you dig up this rubbish?

[Horus]

You've stated this before. Please explain where you dig up this rubbish?

What facts do you question and can Proved wrong?

[andrewcuff]

What facts do you question and can Proved wrong?

The fact which I put in bold in my previous post. The "fact" that Floyd has been "Fighter of the Year a combined 10 times".

That is absolute nonsense and you know it.

[Horus]

The fact which I put in bold in my previous post. The "fact" that Floyd has been "Fighter of the Year a combined 10 times".

That is absolute nonsense and you know it.

Post the references I posted and prove it wrong....plz plz

[andrewcuff]

Post the references I posted and prove it wrong....plz plz

This is a post of yours:

if you want to make that argument go ahead...lol
Floyd did his undefeated while becoming Undisputed champion in 3 divisions and Fighter of the year a combined 10 times..With fighting for 11 years with being a Offical World Champion 10 of them...

i got stats for pages...

Fighter of the Year a combined 10 times? 1998 and 2007 are the only times Floyd has won this award. 1 + 1 does not equal 10.

[Horus]

This is a post of yours:



Fighter of the Year a combined 10 times? 1998 and 2007 are the only times Floyd has won this award. 1 + 1 does not equal 10.

Plz read Post #28 again carefully to be understand what 10 COMBINE (foy) I was talking about

[andrewcuff]

[*] Ring Fighter of the Year: 2 times 1998 and 2007[*] WBC Fighter of the year 3 times : 1998,2001,2007[*] World Boxing Hall of Fame’s Fighter of the Year: 2002[*] USA Today Fighter of the Year: 2007[*] Boxing Writers Association of America Fighter of the Year:2007[*] ESPN fighter of the year:2007[*] ******* Fighter Of The Year: 2007[*] Undefeated[/LIST]

So basically you're awarding 6 Fighter of the Year awards for 2007? Ha! See what I mean, nonsense.

When talking FOTY, people generally refer to Ring ****zine, or at least one awarding body. You don't sc**** the barrel and count 6 FOTY award from 1 year

[JAB5239]

Plz read Post #28 again carefully to be understand what 10 COMBINE (foy) I was talking about

And you don't think those FOY status' are debatable? You have them all laid out nice nice, but wouldn't one cancel out another if its not unanimus? Reasonable people recognize he's a two time fighter of the year.