The Top 20 All-Time Greatest P4P List

[GhostofDempsey]

Dude, I've proven you wrong on this site a billion times. Just because you don't cop to being wrong doesn't mean it didn't happen.

Remember when you posted about Ashley Babbitt's killer and I told you that you had the wrong guy? Was that a failure? lol




Why is it that every time I try to talk boxing with you, you get upset and bring up all this other extracurricular activity. I know why.


Because when it comes to boxing facts, you can't hang. Point blank period. So you deflect.


I'll ask you again. Were there title fights in NY when all fights were technically considered exhibitions? Yes or no? Keep it boxing. Let's see who was right and who was wrong, shall we?

You’ve only proven me wrong in your own biased and distorted head. You’re a legend in your own mind. Any time I have been wrong I admitted it, unlike you. You’re worse than a woman.

[GhostofDempsey]

I'm supposedly stalking him....but here he is referring to me out of the blue.


I wouldn't have even quoted you if not for this post. But keep playing victim if you like.

How am I talking about you? I never mentioned you, you’re a paranoid psychotic.

[GhostofDempsey]

Yes I was referring to you, you're absolutely correct about Johnson signing to fight McVey,Jeannette,and Langford.
Dempsey is my favourite fighter,but that certainly does not make him immune from criticism,he must shoulder some of the blame for not defending against Wills.
The question is how much ? I think you both lack some objectivity on those respective names,but Ghost O D has a by far the worst case, to the point where he thinks Johnson ducked Kid Cotton his protege and sparring partner!
Feel free to criticize any of my posts, but perhaps leaving out the long catalogue of infantile insults Marchgiano feels necessary to add to his. bombast.

Battling Jim is the smoking gun that proved you wrong. You’ll never live that down nor will he.

[Ivich]

Battling Jim is the smoking gun that proved you wrong. You’ll never live that down nor will he.

Battling Jim who drew with Jack Johnson when Jack had a broken arm and Jack got only $5000 for his trouble?
Battling Jim who beat George Kid Cutler?
That Battling Jim?
What won't I ever live down?

[travestyny]

Yes I was referring to you, you're absolutely correct about Johnson signing to fight McVey,Jeannette,and Langford.
Dempsey is my favourite fighter,but that certainly does not make him immune from criticism,he must shoulder some of the blame for not defending against Wills.
The question is how much ? I think you both lack some objectivity on those respective names,but Ghost O D has a by far the worst case, to the point where he thinks Johnson ducked Kid Cotton his protege and sparring partner!
Feel free to criticize any of my posts, but perhaps leaving out the long catalogue of infantile insults Marchgiano feels necessary to add to his. bombast.

It's all good. I tend to treat people with the same amount of respect they treat me with. You've always been respectful no matter how testy we've gotten with each other. No matter what we disagree on you've earned my respect.

[GhostofDempsey]

Battling Jim who drew with Jack Johnson when Jack had a broken arm and Jack got only $5000 for his trouble?
Battling Jim who beat George Kid Cutler?
That Battling Jim?
What won't I ever live down?

It was a duck orfJeannette, plain and simple.

[Ivich]

You’ve only proven me wrong in your own biased and distorted head. You’re a legend in your own mind. Any time I have been wrong I admitted it, unlike you. You’re worse than a woman.

He thinks Jack Johnson having an exhibition bout with Jack Murray is proof that Johnson should have defended his title against his sparring partner Kid Cotton!The man's unhinged on the subject of Johnson!

[Ivich]

It was a duck orfJeannette, plain and simple.

Its a matter of public record that Johnson signed to defend against Jeannette twice,and that the two attempts were vetoed by the NYAC with threats of suspension for any promoter who put the fight on.The promoters the McMahon Brothers, the NYAC,and Jeannette himself all made public statements about it.In his statement to the press Jeannette said," Ir I do not blame Johnson in any way for the failure of the fight to happen".Its been posted here, as has the promoters and NYAC's statements. Sorry Sunshine, you'll have to find another stick to beat Johnson with.

[travestyny]

How am I talking about you? I never mentioned you, you’re a paranoid psychotic.

Because we had a pages long debate about it, and now you want to say it wasn't about me?


Simple. Then tell us who you were referring to? I'm sure with a simple search we can get it all sorted.

[travestyny]

You’ve only proven me wrong in your own biased and distorted head. You’re a legend in your own mind. Any time I have been wrong I admitted it, unlike you. You’re worse than a woman.

Well then like I said it's very simple.

Answer the question. Were there championship fights in NY during the Frawley act?


You said no. I said yes . Do you still have that opinion or did I prove you wrong.

Stop ducking and answer.



Oh, and I've asked you this before too and I'll ask you again. What have I been wrong about? Let me know!!!!