The Greatest NFL Quarterbacks Of All Time

[KingDosia]

Theres no way you can actully consider Brett Farve as one of the best quarterbacks ever.
Marino had good stats, but the guy just wasnt a winner.
When I look at this question I think about starting a franchise or being in the superbowl and picking a qb.Those are not the guys I would pick.

If I'm picking for the best QB in that sense I want, The most reliable Most intelligent with the most athletic ability possible. This is an opinion that can very, but since I'd also be fantasy picking my other players I chose Peyton Manning. Troy Aikmen, Maybe Montana. Brady is up there, but still you couldn't convince me he's the best for even that situation.

[SonnyG8R]

...Neither Aikman nor Bradshaw is in anyone's top five list so your kind of helping the arguement against Brady being on there. He is not top five all time by any ****ing stretch and anyone who thinks that is definitely not worth arguing with.

An argument can be made for both Aikman and Bradshaw. I don't have either on my top 5 but if I really thought about it either one or both could make my top 10. There are many ways of evaluating nfl quarterbacks so for anyone to say theirs is the only way is beyond laughable. If you want to claim that Brady isn't one of the top 5 I disagree but I can accept your opinion. If you claim that he isn't even in the discussion for one of the top 10-15 of all time, then I laugh at you and pour the rightful scorn on your lack of sports knowledge. (and by definition, being one of the top 10-15 qb's ever = being one of the greatest qb's of all time).

That's not directed at you Peebs, but all those on this site who think they know it all, but really don't know jack...

[SonnyG8R]

Theres no way you can actully consider Brett Farve as one of the best quarterbacks ever.

Favre is absolutely one of the best ever...

[Easy-E]

Favre is absolutely one of the best ever...

He is not in the same league caliber wise as Marino, Montana, Young, Manning, Brady etc etc, but I digress the point of him not being one of the best ever, I was trying to claim that compariativly to some of the other quarterbacks who are top tier.
I believe Farve is severly overrated.
Thats my opinion, but I think Brett is top 10 all time (which in reality, makes him one of the best ever) but he has always been inconsistant and had severe problems with interceptions.

[Easy-E]

You are talking wins. Points win games the best QB should have provided his team with the most points possible to be considered the greatest right.Whos got more TD's Than Favre? Marino?
Marino is not a winner. He did every humanly thing possilbe to win his stats prove that. There are 10 other guys on the field when you gonna get that through your thick skull. Teams win superbowls. we are arguing best at one position.
Right?

Quarterback is the most important position, and 99% of the time it relates to a team winning games/playoff games/ superbowls.

If a qb throws 45 td's in a season but wins 2 games, do you consider him a premire qb?
I certianly would not.

[KingDosia]

Quarterback is the most important position, and 99% of the time it relates to a team winning games/playoff games/ superbowls.

If a qb throws 45 td's in a season but wins 2 games, do you consider him a premire qb?
I certianly would not.

Weather or not the postion is an important one or the most important one isn't what I'm talking about. You are having trouble with the concept of rating one person out of the 22 starters who take the field I guess. I'm not eliminating the QB I am singling out who would be the best man at that postions for the love of god get the point.

[KingDosia]

**** you all the best qb all time is REX GROSSMAN. end of thread tarded ****s

[Panamaniac]

Have you ever seen Brady throw the ball??
He has a cannon, a far better arm than Montana or Elway, who were never able to throw the ball 60+ yards.

Montana may not have had a cannon for an arm, but he had a much better "arm" than the he was allowed to demonstrate on a regular basis. He pretty much saved it for those few occasions in which he needed a "Hail Mary." The system in which he thrived - The West Coast Offense - did not lend itself to many 60-yard passes.

[Pac_man=God]

John Elway and Johnny Unitas.

[Run]

Theres no way you can actully consider Brett Farve as one of the best quarterbacks ever.
.

Dude, you can't be serious.

1. Most Touchdowns all time.

2. Second in Passing Yards all Time.

3. Most Completions all time.

4. Most Career points scored by Quarterback all time.

5. Most Wins of any Quarterack of all time.

6. Most seasons leading the leauge in Touchdown passes by a QB all time.

7. Most Career starts by any Quarterback all time.

****..........those are just the basics.



| |