The Greatest NFL Quarterbacks Of All Time

[AliKillsTyson]

Ken Stabler.

Not even in the top 20.

My top 5 are probably Montana, Brady, Unitas, Elway, Favre.

Marino is the best pure passer ever.

Manning is great but he doesn't have the leadership abilities to make those around him better and he hasn't risen to the occassion in big games and in key situations consistently, the way those above have.

Steve Young played in Montana's shadow which would be difficult for anyone, but he was great and very under rated imo.

[KingDosia]

I love how one outstanding half year for Brady puts him on the "all time" greatest QB's list. Especially when he's really not doing anything THAT much more special then Manning did two years ago.
Not to mention he needed a pro bowl and future hall of famer wide out and a severe adjustment to the offensive line and scheme on offense as well. lol lets not list Brady as an option lets call it

BRAMOSSACHICK.

[AliKillsTyson]

I love how one outstanding half year for Brady puts him on the "all time" greatest QB's list. Especially when he's really not doing anything THAT much more special then Manning did two years ago.
Not to mention he needed a pro bowl and future hall of famer wide out and a severe adjustment to the offensive line and scheme on offense as well. lol lets not list Brady as an option lets call it

BRAMOSSACHICK.

Belichicken was a neverhasbeen before Bledsoe got hurt and Brady replaced him and Brady was successful long before Moss joined the team. Learn the game. Brady is the real deal.

[Panamaniac]

If Brady is a product of his surroundings and doing what his doing the way he is then what does that make Peyton.. who before Marv, Reggie and Dallas was just as mediocur as Brady maybe a little better, but now Brady has his receivers and well statistically his better then Manning now!

As though it were necessary to point this out - Football is a "team" sport. It isn't fair to detract from the achievements of a QB on the basis of the talent of his receivers. No matter how talented his receiving corps, if a QB does not have the arm or touch to deliver the ball accurately, he's not going to make the routine completions.

Because the quarterback is the driving force behind the offense, even if a completion is 80% run after the catch, the entire gain or TD is attributed to his pass.

[PBDS]

I love how one outstanding half year for Brady puts him on the "all time" greatest QB's list. Especially when he's really not doing anything THAT much more special then Manning did two years ago.
Not to mention he needed a pro bowl and future hall of famer wide out and a severe adjustment to the offensive line and scheme on offense as well. lol lets not list Brady as an option lets call it

BRAMOSSACHICK.

...Yeah, I don't think Brady belongs anywhere near that list at this time.

[KingDosia]

Belichicken was a neverhasbeen before Bledsoe got hurt and Brady replaced him and Brady was successful long before Moss joined the team. Learn the game. Brady is the real deal.

The way **** is written and how you take it are so ****ing opposite I wonder how you get though life. Where did I say Brady wasn't succesfull? He isn't one of the all time greats.

[Easy-E]

I love how one outstanding half year for Brady puts him on the "all time" greatest QB's list. Especially when he's really not doing anything THAT much more special then Manning did two years ago.
Not to mention he needed a pro bowl and future hall of famer wide out and a severe adjustment to the offensive line and scheme on offense as well. lol lets not list Brady as an option lets call it

BRAMOSSACHICK.

So did you forget the 3 superbowl championships he won, which is more than Manning, Marino, Elway, Farve, Grahm, and Unitas.
Not to mention he did this with NO pro bowl wide recievers.
Why is Joe Montana the greatest QB of all time?
He won the most championships.

Lets take this for what its worth, remove your obvious bias, and then take it from there.

[Easy-E]

Belichicken was a neverhasbeen before Bledsoe got hurt and Brady replaced him and Brady was successful long before Moss joined the team. Learn the game. Brady is the real deal.

LOL exacly, Bill had no success in Cleveland or New York, and all of a sudden he comes to New England and is a ****ing genuis?
No thanks, thats all Tommy B.

[KingDosia]

So did you forget the 3 superbowl championships he won, which is more than Manning, Marino, Elway, Farve, Grahm, and Unitas.
Not to mention he did this with NO pro bowl wide recievers.
Why is Joe Montana the greatest QB of all time?
He won the most championships.

Lets take this for what its worth, remove your obvious bias, and then take it from there.

Still not Brady it's Bradpatachick

[-Antonio-]

One thing people should recognize, Brady might have the best offensive line of the past 10 years. He's rarely even touched. The game is a lot easier when you can sit back there and play catch with the best receiving core in the league. Brady is a master at stepping up in the pocket, but I rarely see him move outside the pocket to buy time.

People look at Bulger with all of his weapons and wonder why he's having such a down year. It's because his line is a mess, and every time he drops back he has to run for his life. Switch Brady with Bulger and the Pats are probably still undefeated.