Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

The Greatest NFL Quarterbacks Of All Time

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
    #61
    Originally posted by Dual Champs View Post
    You can use the "great offensive linemen" argument to detract from the achievements of most of the great nfl qb's. Aikmen had the best offensive lines in the history of the league. Montana had a great line, Bradshaw had a great line, etc. Bottom line is Brady is one of the great qb's of the last 30 years. Anyone who can't see that isn't worth arguing with...


    ...Neither Aikman nor Bradshaw is in anyone's top five list so your kind of helping the arguement against Brady being on there. He is not top five all time by any ****ing stretch and anyone who thinks that is definitely not worth arguing with.

    Comment

      #62
      Originally posted by PBDS View Post
      ...So is Bradshaw. So what??
      Bradshaw has 2 more career touchdowns than interceptions, and has a 70% passer rating.
      Its about Rings and statistics, and Im assuming that Brady's stats will continue to be great for the next few years and he will win at LEAST 1 more superbowl.

      Comment

        #63
        Originally posted by PBDS View Post
        ...Neither Aikman nor Bradshaw is in anyone's top five list so your kind of helping the arguement against Brady being on there. He is not top five all time by any ****ing stretch and anyone who thinks that is definitely not worth arguing with.
        My argument is that when his career is over he will be one of the greatest quarterbacks ever.

        Comment

          #64
          Originally posted by KingDosia View Post
          My argument is applied to Montana and Elway. I'd pick Marino to be the sports best ever in the QB position followed by Farvre. Both had mediocre teams and still managed great feats in the game. And Favre has those prescious rings to go with it. If you wanna holler superbowls where is Bradshaw on the list?
          I factor superbowl rings and statistics into considering who is the best ever.

          Comment

            #65
            Originally posted by Easy-E View Post
            Bradshaw has 2 more career touchdowns than interceptions, and has a 70% passer rating.
            Its about Rings and statistics, and Im assuming that Brady's stats will continue to be great for the next few years and he will win at LEAST 1 more superbowl.

            ....The point is, you were using Brady's 3 super bowl wins as some sort of affirmation when Bradshaw clearly proves that theory wrong. Aikman and Staubach had excellent career stats and Aikman was one of the highest rated playoff and superbowl QB's ever.

            Comment

              #66
              **** this superbowl bull ****. When was the last time a QB got to and won the Superbowl by himself? Records, Player Stats and how the particular position carried the team or how important the player was to the team do count in this argument. Marino, Favre. case closed.

              Comment

                #67
                Originally posted by PBDS View Post
                ....The point is, you were using Brady's 3 super bowl wins as some sort of affirmation when Bradshaw clearly proves that theory wrong. Aikman and Staubach had excellent career stats and Aikman was one of the highest rated playoff and superbowl QB's ever.
                so your saying that should not be factored in to who is the greatest qb ever?

                Comment

                  #68
                  Originally posted by KingDosia View Post
                  **** this superbowl bull ****. When was the last time a QB got to and won the Superbowl by himself? Records, Player Stats and how the particular position carried the team or how important the player was to the team do count in this argument. Marino, Favre. case closed.
                  Theres no way you can actully consider Brett Farve as one of the best quarterbacks ever.
                  Marino had good stats, but the guy just wasnt a winner.
                  When I look at this question I think about starting a franchise or being in the superbowl and picking a qb.
                  Those are not the guys I would pick.

                  Comment

                    #69
                    Originally posted by Easy-E View Post
                    so your saying that should not be factored in to who is the greatest qb ever?


                    ...It's not the end all be all as Bradshaw, Aikman, and Staubach can attest to. Hell, you have guys like Trent Dilfer and Doug Williams with Superbowl wins to their credit.

                    Comment

                      #70
                      Originally posted by Easy-E View Post
                      Theres no way you can actully consider Brett Farve as one of the best quarterbacks ever.
                      Marino had good stats, but the guy just wasnt a winner.
                      When I look at this question I think about starting a franchise or being in the superbowl and picking a qb.
                      Those are not the guys I would pick.
                      You are talking wins. Points win games the best QB should have provided his team with the most points possible to be considered the greatest right.Whos got more TD's Than Favre? Marino?
                      Marino is not a winner. He did every humanly thing possilbe to win his stats prove that. There are 10 other guys on the field when you gonna get that through your thick skull. Teams win superbowls. we are arguing best at one position.
                      Right?

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X
                      TOP