How would you rate Manny if he KOs Thurman and then decisions Spence?

[hugh grant]

No one credible has Manny any higher than #2 in his generation or top 25 ATG. The only ones who post stuff like this are diehard fans like yourself.

You can't separate your fandom and lust from your evaluation of his career.

More people think Pac is greater than floyd.
If Pac then beats thurman, on top of all he's done he is goat. Floyd s career ended at 38 with berto. Pac s gone onto beat thurman which surpasses anything Floyd s done. Floyd s not shown he can achieve anything at 39. Pac s fearless in his drive to cement legacy, Floyd not so much

[The Big Dunn]

More people think Pac is greater than floyd.
If Pac then beats thurman, on top of all he's done he is goat. Floyd s career ended at 36 with berto. Pac s gone onto beat thurman which surpasses anything Floyd s done. Floyd s not shown he can achieve anything at 39. Pac s fearless in his drive to cement legacy, Floyd not so much

No they don't. You are making that up.

Floyd doesn't have to fight because he made hundreds of millions and can live off his wealth. Manny is fighting because he owes taxes and needs money to fund his and his family's campaigns for office in the Philippines. If you need to lie about why they are fighting to make Manny look better, be my guest.

This site allows you to post whatever you want. So long as Manny continues to be ranked behind Floyd in all credible rankings of ATG fighters, nothing you post really matters.

Like your sig reads Manny is nothing but a former flyweight coming to end of career, past prime with no kos for ages. No need to stray from that narrative.

[hugh grant]

No they don't. You are making that up.

Floyd doesn't have to fight because he made hundreds of millions and can live off his wealth. Manny is fighting because he owes taxes and needs money to fund his and his family's campaigns for office in the Philippines. If you need to lie about why they are fighting to make Manny look better, be my guest.

This site allows you to post whatever you want. So long as Manny continues to be ranked behind Floyd in all credible rankings of ATG fighters, nothing you post really matters.

Like your sig reads Manny is nothing but a former flyweight coming to end of career, past prime with no kos for ages. No need to stray from that narrative.

jmm said Pac is without question best of era. If Pac beats thurman jmm might think Pac s goat also.
Pac beating thurman don't definitely make him goat. Nothing in life's definite apart from death.
But Pac s in the equation.

[The D3vil]

It moves him up the ATG list for sure.

Both Thurman & Spence have occupied P4P top 10 lists for the past 3 years.

If a 40 year old man beats both of them, especially one who started his career at 108 lbs, then there's definitely GOAT arguments to be made for him.

[boliodogs]

Very high but I already rate him very high. He is way past prime and those two wins would not make his losses go away. He might beat Thurman but he has a snowball's chance in hell of beating Spence.

[QueensburyRules]

If he gets two clear victories over 2 young lions where do you rate Manny all time?

- -Manny already #1 p4p.

You been under a rock on Pluto?

[.!WAR MIKEY!.]

hes a ATG, it will only increase he ranking in that list doesnt Hurt it.

[Kuyukut]

pac's the greatest fighter of this generation with fraud jr running distant second or third best fighter at this time.

pac winning against thurman and spence makes pac the goat!

[Htown-Finest]

If that was to happen which unlikely. He would set himself to fight BUD or fantasy Floyd rematch

He’ll break top 10 greatest ever if not already.Something Floyd has no chance of ever being. People easily forget about mannys run from Barrera until time he got put to sleep by Marquez

Hey. If Bernard Hopkins could fight forever. Never know

[ez396979]

Just because Floyd didn't fight him that doesn't mean he ducked him. If what you said was valid, then I should give Floyd credit for Corrales, Castillo and Maidana, all guys Manny (based on this logic) ducked.

STop with the ****** make believe theories where you as a Manny fan try to elevate him over Floyd simply because you like Manny.

Just accept the fact that while he had a great career, Floyd's was just better. You make Manny look weaker when you try and gerrymander Floyd's opponent's because those same theories lower manny's opposition even more when applied to his career.

I remember talks of Thurman v Mayweather. Corrales/Castillo v Pac? What weight was Manny back then? No way they were ever on his radar.

If Thurman was his mandatory at the time he fought Berto, then there's way more of a case for a duck there.