How would you rate Manny if he KOs Thurman and then decisions Spence?

[Pac=Duran]

If he gets two clear victories over 2 young lions where do you rate Manny all time?

[The Big Dunn]

I think he climbs a few notches for sure. If you are asking does he pass Floyd-no. Why? Because Thurman, while young, isn't as good right now as Manny, Mosley, Corrales, JMM, ODH or Cotto were when Floyd fought them even though they were older than Thurman.

[FeFist]

2nd best of his generation... just behind Mayweather.

[Flo_Raiden]

I think it further elevates his ATG for sure. People will disagree with me but I rate Pac a little higher than Floyd so beating 2 undefeated guys like Thurman and Spence would be icing on the cake.

But let's not jump ahead of ourselves just yet and see how Manny looks against Thurman.

[Left Hook Tua]

All gravy

Pac is at a point in his career where every win can add to his legacy but can't really hurt it

He's 40

[IceTrayDaGang]

I think he climbs a few notches for sure. If you are asking does he pass Floyd-no. Why? Because Thurman, while young, isn't as good right now as Manny, Mosley, Corrales, JMM, ODH or Cotto were when Floyd fought them even though they were older than Thurman.

but you just gonna ignored spence? let us know if spence is as good as mosley, jmm, odh, cotto?

[Left Hook Tua]

2nd best of his generation... just behind Mayweather.

Lol lol

So funny

Floyd has an 0 and more money

Resume and legacy goes to pac

[The Big Dunn]

but you just gonna ignored spence? let us know if spence is as good as mosley, jmm, odh, cotto?

Spence IMO is as highly respected as all of them except he is not a top 2 or 3 p4p like Manny and JMM were when Floyd beat them. I believe he is between 5-7 in most rankings, which is where Corrales was when Floyd beat him.

That stated, if Manny beats Spence and Crawford, I think we can have a really good debate.

Floyd was 36 when he beat Canelo. Does pac have any win as good as that beyond age 35?

[RuleOfTheSpear]

Pac won't be retiring till 2022.

2022 is the Philippine Election. I think he has plans to run for President since the incumbent will back him if he runs.

He already transcended boxing when he came to politics. Moreso if he becomes President.

[IceTrayDaGang]

Spence IMO is as highly respected as all of them except he is not a top 2 or 3 p4p like Manny and JMM were when Floyd beat them. I believe he is between 5-7 in most rankings, which is where Corrales was when Floyd beat him.

That stated, if Manny beats Spence and Crawford, I think we can have a really good debate.

jmm wasnt either when floyd fought him. and pac? you mean the same pac that died and came back to life already?

that stated, if pac beat thurman, it will definitely put him above floyd since thurman was the fighter floyd ducked. i think this hold more value that a win over spence or crawford (not proven).