P4P#1 is Vacant?

[New England]

well floyd just won a ud to win a title in a new division and manny arguably lost his last fight to a lightweight

months ago

and floyd performance against cotto was not a strong showing in the least.


i dont neccessarily have tons of issues with the ranking

it's the timing.


it's very clearly a marketing ploy

[Daddy T]

joint number two is best - until they fight eachother they cannot prove who should be number 1 and saying one over the other is just opinion. manny certainly looked poor against marquez but floyd looked beatable against cotto - i only gave cotto 3 rounds but only had mayweather being completely dominant in a rare few, the rest were fairly close with floyd edging them.

[Bushbaby]

joint number two is best - until they fight eachother they cannot prove who should be number 1 and saying one over the other is just opinion. manny certainly looked poor against marquez but floyd looked beatable against cotto - i only gave cotto 3 rounds but only had mayweather being completely dominant in a rare few, the rest were fairly close with floyd edging them.

Cotto owned round 8.

[Daddy T]

Cotto owned round 8.

yeah that was his round alright pity he couldn't keep it up in round 9

[4Corners]

Floyd took the first 5 rounds, I don't see how anyone could have given Cotto any of those. Round 5, who some gave to Cotto, Floyd was on the ropes but out fought Cotto the whole round off the ropes and out landed him.

Round 6 was Cotto. Round 7 was Floyd. Round 8 was Cotto.

Round 9 was close, could have gone either way. No problem with either fighter winning that round.

Floyd won rounds 10-12 clearly.

118-110/117-111.

[Roman Moreno]

Until they fight each other, just leave them tied at #2.

It's ridiculous how much they are ducking each other.

good move by The Ring

good move, none of them deserve it until they fight each other

its right imo.

pacman doesnt deserve to be p4p number 1 because he arguably just lost to marquez, and has fought a couple of well past it guys like margarito and mosley.

mayweather doesnt deserve to be p4p number 1 either because he hasnt been willing to fight the best to prove it.

joint number two is best - until they fight eachother they cannot prove who should be number 1 and saying one over the other is just opinion. manny certainly looked poor against marquez but floyd looked beatable against cotto - i only gave cotto 3 rounds but only had mayweather being completely dominant in a rare few, the rest were fairly close with floyd edging them.

I find it hilarious that the ring would try to make their P4P more credible then their own titles.

[Roman Moreno]

Wow, Ring has been going downhill since GBP bought it. SAD. I've always thought of Ring's ratings above the other belts. Will now have to rethink that with all these new rule changes.

Truth

wow you should start a website. i had no idea GBP owned the ring
good job !

New to the sport or just trolling?

and they made floyd the #1 jr mw and cotto #2 and moved canelo to #3? so he can just rematch cotto for the ring belt at 154???strange

What's strange is that Cotto can fight Vanes Martirosyan for the Ring belt.

[Roman Moreno]

The ring doesn't want no vacant division champs. So they change rules. But, have a vacant #1 P4P guy to bring credibility?

What universe does that make sense?

[Check_hooks]

no one gives a damn about who the ring thinks is P4P after oscar bought it

Everyone knows Pac is P4P and has been since before the oscar fight

Just look at floyds last 2 fights, a washed up cotto, and a 24 year old kid in ortiz who he had to sucker punch to win

Pac's last 2 fights, a first ballot HOFer in Marquez and a undefeated #1 ranked 140 pound fighter in the world (who would beat floyd, Cotto and Ortiz easily)

[hugh grant]

Pac is No1 he beat common opponents much easier. It has been argued by FLoyd fans that on some of the opponents Floyd might have beat them when they were marginally better.

Therefore Pac is no1 until Floyd beats Pac to prove its not all talk. Thats the fairest it can be and anything else is showing favouritism and reaching and trying to make Floyd not fight Pac.