Who Is Ranked Higher On The ATG List of These 3? (Mosley, Oscar & Tito)

[them_apples]

I think Trinidad, in his prime days he was a beast.

[Golden Boy 360]

i made a thread about this a while back and it had like 20 responses and this one gets 70? WTF!

[IMDAZED]

Trinidad may have dominated his fights, but he didnt face the kind of guys that De La Hoya did either. look at the guys that Oscar went to controversial decision with...Ike Quartey, Pernell Whitaker, and Trinidad himself. Trinidad may have also fought Whitaker, but I believe that Whitaker had been caught with ******* and might have had to go to rehab before the Trinidad fight. So the Whitaker that Oscar fought was better than the one Trinidad fought.

Who knows if Trinidad would have beaten a prime Quartey? and most people have De La Hoya winning the Trinidad fight too.

just for the record, I think Trinidad still has the better record at 147. He beat most the guys that DLH did except earlier and more prime, plus guys like Campas and Blocker. but Oscar really isnt that far behind, and you cant completely blame him for his close fights at 147.

the thing that puts DLH above Trinidad and Mosley for me is his run at 135 and 140, which was actually pretty good even if he didnt have any huge prime names on there.

I don't know, black. We both agree that Tito had the better resume at 147 but I think what he did at 154 and 160 is better than what Oscar did in the lower weights, beating down a prime pound for pounder and ruining him, clearing out the division, another top 20 fighter and murdering beating a respectable champ in Joppy.