Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

I reckon Dempsey would have battered Greb

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    I reckon Dempsey would have battered Greb

    It's 1920, Jack's in training to fight Miske in a few months. He had some other boys he was working with but needed someone who could push him slickly. He had boys for power and toughness and needed some helpers to get his reflexes and speed up.

    First they bring in Panama Joe. Joe would enter the sparring ring with Jack just after Tate was finished. So a fresh Panama vs a warmed up Jack, sparring though. Panama does very well and Jack-n-Team are very happy with him so they keep him on board for the remainder of the training camp. That's about 40 pounds difference between the fighters, guessimate from their fight weights. I dunno Jack's walk around or Joes, but, in a training camp I assume both men are fit. Later Joe would try, like everyone else, to get a Dempsey fight, but, Bill Breenan was chosen instead. I don't think Bill and Joe ever fought.

    Nearer toward the end Harry was brought in as well. Panama and Greb, together, both, seems massive overkill for Miske, but you gotta give Jack credit here. The only other slick man at the time on that level was Norfolk. He literally gathered the best slick men of his era to improve his slickness even though he was just fighting Miske. Massively prepped and I think pointing that out is worth a little aside to the point.

    Panama and Greb, being smaller men, were shifted days so that Dempsey didn't put too much damage on one or the other and always had a fresh, lightning fast, hard hitting, slick boxer to train with.

    Greb, not much liking how he has displayed with Jack would approach Panama for a sparring session. Greb seems to have wanted to make a name for himself in the camp and was thwarted by Dempsey himself. Dempsey, having worked with Panama a bit longer, had given Panama more chances to pull something off and look good for the boys in camp, which Panama had, but Greb hadn't yet.

    This is a fresh Greb vs a Dempsey who went rounds with Tate first and holding back because he doesn't want to KO Greb and ruin his own training. If that doesn't say Dempsey would have battered the kid in a proper fight then sparring means **** all to proper fights period. That's some strong evidence Jack simply hit too hard for Greb and though may not have been as slick he was slick enough to put that power on Greb. Something Tunney and Norfolk, the Greb beaters, lacked. I wouldn't say Tunney or Norfolk hit like kittens but by all accounts Jack should be that next level in power. He's either a massive puncher, or, the entire era of folks who watched him all agreed to lie about it. Obviously one should lean former.

    That's it though. I reckon Dempsey over Greb solely because Greb got frustrated with Dempsey and the training team because Dempsey didn't let him look good where as Panama had plenty of situations he looked good in.

    Panama, of course, agrees to Greb's request and the boys set to. Both are fresh. It was apparently a great showing by both men but got a bit too heated and flirting with one hurting the other at some point so the team put a rest to it and called it even. It is the only encounter between the two. Panama did prep Norfolk though.

    Panama "draws" Greb, Panama has "wins" over Dempsey. Dempsey "wins" over Greb and Panama. Greb, the man you'd think would look best here, walks away with a "draw" to Panama and nothing else. It's rather similar to the Battling Gahee story. Gahee thought he'd go into camp and shake things up. Gahee got battered and became scared then was cut, useless to the champion Dempsey. Greb did suffer as bad, but, Greb you'd except more from, no? By all accounts the great Harry Greb was merely serviceable for Dempsey's needs. Not even close to more than what Jack bargained for. Harry ****in' Greb though...ya get me?


    I got most of this from Sundowners and a little from just google searchin'.




    billeau2 billeau2 likes this.

    #2
    Battling nelson, jim jeffries, abe at tell to max bear, Tony canzoneri, joe louis ; whom did the great legends of boxing rate as the greatest ever? At Michael Hunnicutt Facebook, Branford , Conn Mr Hunnicutt has posted dozens of newspaper clippings of the greatest fighters in history of whom were the greatest ever. Most not seen in decades

    Comment


      #3
      No middleweight is getting in the ring with an ATG heavyweight puncher and leaving conscious. First well placed solid blow ends the fight and Greb himself realized this.

      Comment


        #4
        Originally posted by HOUDINI563 View Post
        No middleweight is getting in the ring with an ATG heavyweight puncher and leaving conscious. First well placed solid blow ends the fight and Greb himself realized this.
        When Gahee was kicked out of Jack's camp he left making a comment about Norfolk, who was making waves pushing for a Dempsey fight. Gahee said something to the effect of before feeling his power I thought I could whoop Dempsey, but after feeling it I think Dempsey would whoop a whole room full of Norfolks.

        Probably truer than it isn't.

        Comment


          #5
          - -Had Jack not wasted 3 yrs trying to fight Wills, good chance he ends up fighting Greb before Tunney. Instead we got the Hollywood ring rust Dempsey vs Tunney...

          Comment


            #6
            Originally posted by HOUDINI563 View Post
            No middleweight is getting in the ring with an ATG heavyweight puncher and leaving conscious. First well placed solid blow ends the fight and Greb himself realized this.
            Well in theory this is true but dempsey didnt exactly walk through miske, bennan and gibbons... And greb beat all 3 of those. The reality may have been different and dempsey was like 25lbs heavier than greb. We aren't talking ggg vs aj here.

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by cfang View Post

              Well in theory this is true but dempsey didnt exactly walk through miske, bennan and gibbons... And greb beat all 3 of those. The reality may have been different and dempsey was like 25lbs heavier than greb. We aren't talking ggg vs aj here.
              Dempsey stopped Brennan and Miske and dominated Gibbons.

              Greb traded decisions with Gibbons and never had the power to stop Miske or Brennan.

              We are still talking about one of the hardest ****ers the game has seen against a MW considered a pitty-pat puncher.

              Even Greb said 'I think I can beat him so long as I can stay off the floor.'

              Comment


                #8
                Greb knew he would have to be nearly perfect...and for the bout to be around 10 rounds or less. But I've no doubt he believes he could have done it. Whether he would have or not, unfortunately, we didn't get a chance to see.


                The way fans have been clamoring for Greb footage, would have been really cool to see it vs. Dempsey.
                Last edited by travestyny; 04-26-2021, 02:29 PM.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Here we go again, LOL

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Originally posted by travestyny View Post
                    Greb knew he would have to be nearly perfect...and for the bout to be around 10 rounds or less. But I've no doubt he believes he could have done it. Whether he would have or not, unfortunately, we didn't get a chance to see.


                    The way fans have been clamoring for Greb footage, would have been really cool to see it vs. Dempsey.
                    It is too bad that it was a Fitz promotion and not Rickard. It looks as though Fitz put much effort into promoting the sparing session with the press but in 1920 he probably didn't have the foresight (or maybe the money) to film the sparring.

                    But I would suggest that there is a better chance of that sparing session existing than any of his fights (save Jim Jacobs insistence he saw three frames of Greb-Tunney I once.)

                    That week Fitz really looked to make a big deal of Greb being in camp -- the Miske undercard included Greb , Langford, and Tate (Dempsey's sparing partner.)

                    This is also when Fitz (supposedly) told Greb to win a few quick ones and he would make a Dempsey fight. But Dempsey jumped to Rickard and Brennan/Carpentier.
                    travestyny travestyny likes this.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    X
                    TOP