Dempsey v Tunney who wins in their primes?

[solidman]

I have to say i think it would have been the same result with Tunney winning on points.

[Bronson66]

I have to say i think it would have been the same result with Tunney winning on points.

Edited

[GhostofDempsey]

Dempsey lost to inactivity and a long count in his fights to Tunney. A more prime Dempsey would have been faster with sharper reflexes. I think Dempsey would win by decision and maybe even stoppage.

[Biledriver]

Dempsey. The Dempsey that Tunney beat was a pale imitation of his prime years.

[QueensburyRules]

I have to say i think it would have been the same result with Tunney winning on points.

- - I’d say U lose U wad and go begging.

[match maker]

Tunney wins. Dempsey had issues with good movers.

[QueensburyRules]

Tunney wins. Dempsey had issues with good movers.

- - What good movers?

Prime Dempsey had some of the top moves in boxing history...

[match maker]

- - What good movers?

Prime Dempsey had some of the top moves in boxing history...

Meehan and Tunney come to mind.

[Anomalocaris]

Either Dempsey by blitzing Gene early or a clinical Tunney masterclass.

I favour the latter result.

[QueensburyRules]

Meehan and Tunney come to mind.

- - 4 round exhibitions with Meehan mean nothing. Tunney as good as he was got the inactive Dempsey and was lucky to survive.