Good Fellas Or Scarface?...

[Walt Liquor]

Scarface could be about 20 minutes shorter and nothing would be missed. It's a good flick but Goodfellas is better in just about everyway. Both are ATG Gangster movies IMO...

Good deal. We disagee but both movies are atg's.

[Mushroom]

Haven't watched either in ages. Think I might have to watch them both tomorrow.

[Walt Liquor]

Just because there hasn't been a cuban gangster movie doesn't make it original. There a million rags to riches and coming up movies that existed before Scarface. Where the guy hails from is irrelevant, the concept is not original.

Goodfellas, while not entirely accurate is based on true bad-assery.

Not fiction.

Advantage: Goodfellas

so every true story>fiction or just in this case?

you're an idiot. Being based on a true story doesn't make it original.

Under you guidelines, there are no original movies, lol!!!!!!!

[TBear]

I know alot of people that think Scarface is one of the greatest, but personally I thought Good fellas was better done.

[Bretty Poy32]

carlito's way = scaface vol II

[Dirt E Gomez]

Good to see Scarface losing. One of the most overrated films of all time.

Whereas Good Fellas is a classic in every sense of the word.

[BOLLOCKS]

Nothing incenstous about it. Tony just didn't like scumbags like himself with his sister.

What a hypocrite.

[TheNegation]

you're an idiot. Being based on a true story doesn't make it original.

Under your guidelines, there are no original movies, lol!!!!!!!

I never said that is being a true story means it's original, I simply said the fact that it's based on a true story, real people, and real crimes, it trumps a fictional story about a guy who hopped off a boat, got rich, and died in a blaze of *******. Clearly you are the idiot because you can't read.

[Walt Liquor]

I never said that is being a true story means it's original, I simply said the fact that it's based on a true story, real people, and real crimes, it trumps a fictional story about a guy who hopped off a boat, got rich, and died in a blaze of *******. Clearly you are the idiot because you can't read.

In your poston pg 7, you said scarface original bwaaaaaa.

The ridiculous summary above shows that you are unable to appreciate a good story.

And to you, who seems to think that at any point in history, anyone was able to have a ****ton of drugs pop out in front of people in a visiting room of a federal prison and there were no reprecssions is legit. You, my friend are the one who does not know how things work.

[TheNegation]

In your poston pg 7, you said scarface original bwaaaaaa.

It's not. Rags to Riches movies and stories have been done to death. This one just had an R rating slapped on it and a completely unrealistic ending. Nobody even on ******* can get shot with pistols, smg's and assault rifles and still be able to live, much less taunt the people shooting him.

The ridiculous summary above shows that you are unable to appreciate a good story.

I can appreciate a good story. But there is nothing amazingly original or confounding about Scarface.

And to you, who seems to think that at any point in history, anyone was able to have a ****ton of drugs pop out in front of people in a visiting room of a federal prison and there were no reprecssions is legit. You, my friend are the one who does not know how things work.

Have you ever heard of prison gangs, and the mafia paying people off?

FFS, in the movie you can clearly see Henry Hill paying the prison guard so he can sell his drugs and collect more from his wife.

Let me ask you this. How is it that someone can run out of a motel, chainsaw in hand and not attract police attention?

How can that man also proceed to get shot, point blank range in the head, and the perpetrator simply escapes by car and never gets caught?