Shortlist for FOTD revealed. Pacquiao didn't make it into the top 3.

[dannnnn]

Pacquiao's resume over the past decade absolutely shits on Ward's, for one thing. The American Sven Ottke should in no way be top three.

Mayweather deserves it over Canelo.

[hugh grant]

My idol in 5 years has a better resume then your idol in 10 years.
Also my dad can beat up your dad.

Im sure in your opinion, but your opinion don't count for much does it. Pacs 5 year resume is better than Floyd. Plus Pac has another 5 years to trounce Floyds resume.
The only way Floyd should get FOTD is to fight from 2020-2025 and get as many great wins as he can and somehow get them backdated to last decade.

[The Big Dunn]

Im sure in your opinion, but your opinion don't count for much does it. Pacs 5 year resume is better than Floyd. Plus Pac has another 5 years to trounce Floyds resume.
The only way Floyd should get FOTD is to fight from 2020-2025 and get as many great wins as he can and somehow get them backdated to last decade.

Name any win Manny has that is better than Floyd beating him? You can't.

[BrometheusBob.]

Between those three, Mayweather is the obvious choice imo.

I liked Pacman as the choice for last decade, and while he is still a skilled fighter I don't see the argument for best of this decade.

[hugh grant]

Name any win Manny has that is better than Floyd beating him? You can't.

Pacs win over Thurman is better than anything on FLoyds resume. 41 year old WW boxers beating young undefeated lions, who are much bigger, less wear and in prime has never been done by former flyweights.
What did Floyd do in beating Pac? Beating naturally much smaller fighters than yourself has been done and often. So why is Floyds win over Pac so damn great? So bradleys win over Pac is better than anything Pacs done? So Horns over Pac is better than anything Pacs done?
Your reasoning ability is suspect to say the least.

[mcdonalds]

Pacs win over Thurman is better than anything on FLoyds resume

But Floyd beat pac

[hectari]

Canelo even being on the list with his ped history is baffling

[mcdonalds]

Because they decided to fight the guy who beat mosley which is a prime cotto. Lol.
Which happens to be the more attractive fight proven by its numbers at that time.
Also better money for top rank as it is An inhouse fight while shane was at golden boy..

They were just being polite to mosley cmon now lol

But after that, margarito stopped Cotto while Mosley stopped Margarito

Mosley was #1 welterweight in the world in 2009/2010, not Cotto

Pac went with Cotto cause he got stopped a year earlier and looked bad against clottey, typical Cherrypick from pac

[hugh grant]

But Floyd beat pac

Read post 155.

[BoomBapTrap]

Name any win Manny has that is better than Floyd beating him? You can't.

Pretty much all his wins from 2005-2010.