Comments Thread For: Robert Garcia: Everyone Loses, Mayweather No Exception

[Snake4380]

Floyd has already lost; the judges gave him a gift decision: see Floyd Mayweather v. Jose Luis Castillo 1.

[The Tase]

nice boxing rebuttal. you really proved me wrong.

Losing to Maidana makes Mayweather an ATG winning doesn't.

fake retiring when the welterweight division was the hottest and deepest in boxing after taking on career 140 pounder ricky hatton at welter (who got beat by collazo in his first 147 fight) doesnt make you an ATG.

Diego Corrales being your best win along with not having EVER faced a LEGIT hall of famer IN THEIR PRIME doesnt make floyd an ATG.

Hall of Famer yes,

ATG, no.

Mayweather is already an ATG whatever he does now advances him further up the list.

LOL yes because beating victor the tree ortiz, and robert freaking guerrero, and amir khan's left overs should surge floyd up the ATG rankings.


lmfaaooooooooooooooooooo

[jbpanama]

Its funny how everybody who Floyd fights are nobody's, and washed up fighters, but PAC fights those same fighters at lighter weights after Floyd already beat them, and he gets praised as fearless and a fighter who always fights the best! The biasness is ridiculous and blount! I guess Canelo wasn't a test? Of course not after the fight, but before the fight was made Canelo was this vicious monster who Floyd would never fight! You can hate all u want, but u have to recognize SKILL and GREATNESS!!!!!!

Truly the Greatest AVOIDER of the Best, in Their Prime!!!

[jbpanama]

And who are these best fighters he's supposely avoided? Would you drops some names and inlighten us, if you will?

Here's a Quick History Lesson for U, Son....
PRIME Mosley, Cotto, Margo, and Pac The Man...
Are U Dumb Enough to Buy into His Excuses, to AVOID Pac???

[icebergisonfire]

Thing is, Floyd isn't like those other fighters. Sugar Ray lost because he fought a ****** fight his first fight against Duran, second fight, boxed him from the outside. Ali is nowhere near the technical skills of Floyd nor does anybody keep themselves in shape like Floyd did once they reached the pinnacle of boxing nor is any of them as remotely skilled as Floyd. Garcia doesn't have faith in his fighter and articles like this continue to show it. You won't show Marcos recent Floyd fights where he's beaten better opposition and made it look ridiculously easy? No! Let's make it movie night, get the popcorn and watch Rocky! He's fought better than Marcos, beat them up easy and one thing is guaranteed, he won't overlook Marcos. UD12 Floyd, easiest bet in sports.

[bopbopbbe]

"Show me an undefeated fighter, and ill show you somebody who hasnt really fought anybody."

That old time tested boxing quote still stands true to this very day.

If you look at all the undefeated "all time greats" they all have serious question marks as to why they retired undefeated:

Rocky Marciano - mob controlled era. should have lost the walcott fight but the mafia wanted to continue his undefeated record schtick.

Ricardo Lopez - who did this guy really fight and how come he never moved up to fight great fighters like carbajal, chiquita gonzalez, and galaxy? He had the frame to move up but stayed in his bulimic model division fighting boxers skinnier than rawandan refugees.

Joe Calzaghe - finally fought big names when both where in their 40s and proceeded to get dropped by both senior citizens. Imagine what would have happened had calzaghe fought hop and roy jr in their primes.

Floyd jr. - Do i even need to go over this? Has never fought a legit hall of famer in their prime and his best win is diego corrales.

If you look in the hall of fame, almost every single true all time great has had losses. It means you were tested, it means you didnt cherry pick.

How you bounce back from a loss is a true mark of a great champion.

Great post!

[jbpanama]

Who do you suggest? Short of moving to 160 or getting someone to move down he doesn't have a lot of options.

Pac the Man, has been calling the Chump out for 5 yrs Now...,
Problem is Pac has KO power in Both Hands, and is as Quick as FRAUD...
If the Self Proclaimed GOAT, is so good, and the Midget "Easy Money"...
Why was the Testing Nonsense, an ISSUE???
Aside from being a Brilliant way to, PUNK OUT!!!

[PunchyPotorff]

Floyd has already lost; the judges gave him a gift decision: see Floyd Mayweather v. Jose Luis Castillo 1.

I don't think he'd have gotten past Hatton if he hadn't paid off Joe Cortez. And I'm not the only one who thinks that.

[Snake4380]

I suppose Floyd-worshipers might argue that Juan Manuel Marquez was in his prime and is a Hall-of-Famer; however, Floyd came in overweight And Marquez had to move up two weight classes. So not sure if that counts as Marquez in his prime.

The major knock on Floyd is he didn't wait for Pacquiao to fight Hatton and then negotiate that fight (before he started the blood-testing crusade) Mayweather ducked Pac in his prime from the De La Hoya win to the Margarito fight. And saying he won't negotiate with Bob Arum is just another lame BS excuse.

[PunchyPotorff]

Quote:
Originally Posted by iniduoh View Post
And who are these best fighters he's supposely avoided? Would you drops some names and inlighten us, if you will?

Here's a Quick History Lesson for U, Son....
PRIME Mosley, Cotto, Margo, and Pac The Man...
Are U Dumb Enough to Buy into His Excuses, to AVOID Pac???

Don't be too hard on Iniduoh... he can't distinguish between ATGs, and ATGs in their prime. HA