Sugar Ray Robinson #1 for eternity?

[New England]

of corse it's possible

it's not likely to happen, but it's possible.

[hugh grant]

SRR was the best of his time. SRR can do no more than that. Pac is the best of this time. Pac can do no more than that. Pac cant be the best of SRRs time, cos he werent born. SRR cant be the best of this time as hes dead.

[The Big Dunn]

SRR was the best of his time. SRR can do no more than that. Pac is the best of this time. Pac can do no more than that. Pac cant be the best of SRRs time, cos he werent born. SRR cant be the best of this time as hes dead.

SRR wouldn't have lost to JMM or Tim. Niether would floyd.

[T.Horton]

no.............

what he said.

i got a few at or near the top of the heap and very few modern fighters records can touch them.

[hugh grant]

SRR wouldn't have lost to JMM or Tim. Niether would floyd.

Pac wouldnt have lost to Turpin or Castillo, and he would have beat Corrales, Gatti, and Hernandez better than FLoyd as well.

[-Lowkey-]

Nobody can defeat Ray in the P4P Rankings. Only Langford and a few others rank near Robinson in P4P Greats of All Time and I say it's still a fair distance.

Times have changed in boxing. No top level fighter will fight more than 4 times a year. They don't really need to with the money they earn. Plus, fighters are carefully managed today.

Men like Ray Robinson, Ray Leonard, Mike Tyson, Muhammed Ali ect. are made once in a life time. People with some sort of special gift.

People wish for more men like them but I always tell them the same thing....Those men can only be cheaply copied because there's never ever going to be another one.

Tyson is not even close to being as great as Robinson, Leonard or Ali why do people say such nonsense I really don't understand it he is without doubt one of the most overrated boxers in the history of the sport. Lewis and Holyfield where both greater.

[The Big Dunn]

Pac wouldnt have lost to Turpin or Castillo, and he would have beat Corrales, Gatti, and Hernandez better than FLoyd as well.

floyd didn't lose to them either so I'm not sure about your point. As for beating them better, only manny fans emphasize that when it comes to fighters floyd beat first. No real boxing fan says that. Can you imagine someone saying well "Hagler beat Hearns better than Leonard did." Real boxing fans don't talk like that.

Manny isn't the best of his ime. SRR would never lose to a Torrecampo level fighter, no matter what age he was or what weight class he was in.

[IronDanHamza]

That might get them top 20. It's far too late for either to make a run at GOAT.

I'd say that would certainly get them in the Top 15-20 mark.

But neither of them are going to do that

Mayweather's got to fight Sergio if not Pacquaio.

[revs1227]

think of it this way

pac could rematch bradley win by ko ...then ko floyd , then move uo , ko martinez and then move up n ko ward

SRR would still be the greatest
so no shot

[IronDanHamza]

think of it this way

pac could rematch bradley win by ko ...then ko floyd , then move uo , ko martinez and then move up n ko ward

SRR would still be the greatest
so no shot

If Pacquaio KO'd Bradley, Mayweather, Martinez and Ward back to back and won Lineal Titles at 147, 160 and 168 on top of his 4 Lineal Title's already then Pacquaio could easily be considered to be the above Ray Robinson.

He of course, won't do that.