Who will be remembered as the greater fighter: Manny Pacquiao or Floyd Mayweather?

[mrpizza-nd_beer]

Floyd Mayweather, after he goes undefeated and finishes his career 49-0 or 50-0 will be remembered as the greatest fighter of his generation, an ATG and top 10 fighter EVER. Whether you like him or hate him that will be the case. Learn to accept it because the avalanche of accolades is incoming.

Last few fights of Floyd were meant to pad his record. A not in his division Hatton, a lightweight Marquez asked to bloat up fat and still cheated on the scales, an old and battered Cotto and Mosley, a sucker punched Ortiz, a slow as molasses Guerrero, and a catchweight muscle depleted Canelo.

He will be remembered just as willy pep, rocky marciano, and joe calzaghe was. No more.

Just look at the poll and magnify it 1000 times in 50 years I don't think Floyd has any chance at all being classified as nowhere near to Pac.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Pacquiao was greater than Floyd before he even got to WW.


and most nonebias knowledgeable fans will agree that what he did to the great 3 is vastly superior than anything Floyd ever did including his current WW "reign"

So true,, Manny, jmm, mab, morales where considered the fab four and compared to Srl, hagler, duran, hearns, As ATG fighting each other all the time.....


People Forget that manny was a Hall of famer 1st ballot before he even fought diaz @135.....

Floyd has better skills, but when faced with a loaded 135 division with casamoyer, freitas, lazcano, spadafora, dorin, johnston,,,
or 140 with undefeated hatton, cotto,plus tsyzu, witter,
or 147 with margs, williams, cotto, mosely, manny

If floyd just had 2 or 3 of those fights at those times alot of haters would shut up

[wazaa.]

Manny is still greater.

Manny beating MAB, Morales and JMM >>>> Floyd's best three wins.

[IronDanHamza]

I would say Mayweather but it's close. They both still have fights to go anyway.

I see a lot of Morales being brought up, I don't even consider that a good win.

And out of all 4 Marquez fights I've never scored any of them for Pacquaio.

[bojangles1987]

I would say Mayweather but it's close. They both still have fights to go anyway.

I see a lot of Morales being brought up, I don't even consider that a good win.

And out of all 4 Marquez fights I've never scored any of them for Pacquaio.

You know how big a hater I am, but I have to admit that where I once thought the answer to this was Pac and without much thought, he's done nothing to enhance his greatness since 2010 and Mayweather has. I won't argue anymore when people say Mayweather is greater, and it's all Pac's fault.

[DARKSEID]

So true,, Manny, jmm, mab, morales where considered the fab four and compared to Srl, hagler, duran, hearns, As ATG fighting each other all the time.....


People Forget that manny was a Hall of famer 1st ballot before he even fought diaz @135.....

Floyd has better skills, but when faced with a loaded 135 division with casamoyer, freitas, lazcano, spadafora, dorin, johnston,,,
or 140 with undefeated hatton, cotto,plus tsyzu, witter,
or 147 with margs, williams, cotto, mosely, manny

If floyd just had 2 or 3 of those fights at those times alot of haters would shut up

Great post.

[The Hammer]

So true,, Manny, jmm, mab, morales where considered the fab four and compared to Srl, hagler, duran, hearns, As ATG fighting each other all the time.....


People Forget that manny was a Hall of famer 1st ballot before he even fought diaz @135.....

Floyd has better skills, but when faced with a loaded 135 division with casamoyer, freitas, lazcano, spadafora, dorin, johnston,,,
or 140 with undefeated hatton, cotto,plus tsyzu, witter,
or 147 with margs, williams, cotto, mosely, manny

If floyd just had 2 or 3 of those fights at those times alot of haters would shut up

Yes.

Floyd avoided many of the best like Casamayor, Tszyu, and Williams. He refused to fight Hatton at 140 and forced him to move up to 147, and then used a shady referee in Cortez to help out.

And he waited until people like Mosley, Cotto and De La Hoya were faded before he fought them.

[VERSION1 (V1)]

Yes.

Floyd avoided many of the best like Casamayor, Tszyu, and Williams. He refused to fight Hatton at 140 and forced him to move up to 147, and then used a shady referee in Cortez to help out.

And he waited until people like Mosley, Cotto and De La Hoya were faded before he fought them.

De la hoya for year said he did not want to fight littel floyd and shane said he had a bad toothache.

if you can pick apart floyd resume you can easliy do the same with pac. cause pac must have wait for shane to get old and istead of fighting zahir raheem he fight a shot morales

[The Tase]

Here's all you need to know, TWO FACTS:

1. FLOYD HAS YET TO FACE A LEGIT HALL OF FAME FIGHTER IN THEIR PRIME.

2. FLOYD'S BEST WIN IS DIEGO CORRALES. SOMEONE WHO MIGHT NOT EVEN MAKE IT TO THE HALL OF FAME.

Pacquiao clearly has the better resume.

[The Big Dunn]

Here's all you need to know, TWO FACTS:

1. FLOYD HAS YET TO FACE A LEGIT HALL OF FAME FIGHTER IN THEIR PRIME.

2. FLOYD'S BEST WIN IS DIEGO CORRALES. SOMEONE WHO MIGHT NOT EVEN MAKE IT TO THE HALL OF FAME.

Pacquiao clearly has the better resume.

every hof'er floyd dominated posters like you find a way to discredit yet when manny beats eric morales AFTER HE LOST TO ZAHIR ****ING RAHEEM, posters like you act like that win is great. stop it.