At 147-154, Prime for Prime, how would Floyd Mayweather Jr fair against these five Pro Boxers he beat in the past?

[djtmal]

If you honestly believe this How was Floyd protecting his 0 when he was calling all these dudes out when they were prime, he was undefeated, they were bigger names and Floyd was the classic high risk, low reward fi

Margarito

Floyd was calling guys out, then back out of the fight

[joseph5620]

Was Mosley Prime against Mayweather? Answer is No.

Again you are missing point here. OP was asking Prime vs Prime. It doesnt matter Floyd was his prime or not

Yes i said that and it is my opinion. We are in forum after all. He did avoid them and its my opinion. It is shared by many, i'm sorry to say to you.

Was Mayweather prime against Mosley? No, and yes it does matter if you're using prime for one and not the other. That defeats the purpose of "prime vs prime."

You claimed Mosley was a "Zombie" when he fought Mayweather. That's a false statement that can't be used as an opinion. You can't lie and hide behind "That's just my opinion." I'm sorry to say to you.

[djtmal]

At those points Floyd was the supremely talented high risk, low reward opponent they all didn’t want to risk losing against. Sadly posters like to forget this or pretend that it was Floyd that didn’t choose to fight these men at these points.

I remember when Margarito was willing to fill that void, and a career high 8 million was on the table, but Floyd thought Carlos Baldymir and Sharmba Mitchell were bigger challenges

[djtmal]

The irony is Manny is never mentioned beating ATG prime WWs he is too small

He did beat Thurman in his prime, who owned two of the ww belts, is a natural ww, undefeated

The best prime natural ww Floyd beat. Damn that might be Victor Ortiz nope Ortiz was a jww

[The Big Dunn]

You really a bitter dude, can't stomach that Floyd's critics aren't buying the excuses for how Floyd managed to duck so many welterweights through backing out of fights, fake retirements, vacations, lockups, etc.

Look at this thread a thread about Floyd fantasy fighting guys who he already fought because they were shopworn versions.

I keep telling you if Floyd would have just fought the best guys in their prime, you wouldn't be on here crying all the time.

Not bitter at all. Annoyed that I have to discuss this with a nut gobbling liar that knows little about the sport.

Floyd didn’t duck anyone. He fought them and beat them. Floyd didn’t wait to fight Fishnets. Floyd didn’t have a toothache. Floyd didn’t turn down the fight over drug testing. He didn’t turn down $40 mil, the highest payday he would have ever made, to fight JMM for $28 mil and get ktfo. Floyd didn’t get his father in laws doctor to give him stitches to avoid the fight.

These are facts you can’t make go away. You can lie about them as always. They never go away at all.

Floyd, no matter how great he is, can’t make grown men fight him when they are in their primes and generate more revenue than him.

He can’t make a potential opponent look like a drug cheat rather than fight him. He cant make a man choose a smaller payday.

You know this but hey, when you’re a nut gobbler you can’t hold the man with nuts you gobble accountable because he might not let you gobble them anymore.

[The Big Dunn]

He was at his peak vs Oscar, Cotto, Hatton, but was shopworn by 2015 when Floyd felt the risk was lowest

Sure he was. Always an excuse because he lost.

[The Big Dunn]

wtf Oscar was fighting Shane, Vargas, Bhop. Trying to get Winky in the ring.

Nobody was clamoring for him to fight lightweight Mayweather hate to bust your bubble.

Floyd got the fight when he moved up to welterweight and beat some halfway decent guys Zab Baldymir, Gatti

Stop making excuses for him not fighting Floyd when he called ODH out. Apply your argument to each boxer equally.

No one was clamoring for Floyd to fight the majority of people that called him out once he was the cash cow. Yet you call them ducks.

When fighters you like don’t fight callouts, you make excuses for them.

[djtmal]

Not bitter at all.

.

Yes you are. You are bitter that the critics aren't buying your excuses.

Did Floyd fight any of those guys in their prime?

[The Big Dunn]

I remember when Margarito was willing to fill that void, and a career high 8 million was on the table, but Floyd thought Carlos Baldymir and Sharmba Mitchell were bigger challenges

You’re lying again.

Bob put the Margs fight on the table once Floyd decided to buy out his TR contract because Bob said he wouldn’t get him the ODH fight.

So Floyd bought out his contract, defeated Baldomir Nov 2006 for the WBC and Ring WW titles and more money than he would’ve earned against Margs ( you left that out) then went up to 154 and beat Fishnets May 2007 for the WBC titles.

Margs was the WBO champ a BS title at that point. Baldo was Ring and WBC champ who just beat Judah and Gatti.

Floyd clearly fought the better opponent for more money.

[djtmal]

Stop making excuses for him not fighting Floyd when he called ODH out.

Gtfoh excuses?

So Oscar who was at ww is supposed to ignore a whole division of welterweights Tito Mosley Quartey to entertain a 130lb Floyd Mayweather who is always too small for somebody his size and prime that can throw a decent combo?

Naw only ww Floyd ignores a whole division of welterweights to cherrypick lightweights