Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

What Makes a Fighter Boring?

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    What Makes a Fighter Boring?

    Saying a fighter is boring is a matter of opinion of course. It's subjective and it can be claimed about anybody and it wouldn't be a false statement. Anyone can find any fighter boring and there's no right or wrong about it.

    So what makes a fighter boring to the one who thinks they are boring?

    I think one factor for me would be lack of knockouts over a long period. If I think there is almost no chance of a KO, it does drop my excitement level to watch them.

    Another factor would be fighters who could press and get a KO but are content to box until the end. As seldom as guys fight now especially, I feel like they should press hard to entertain the fans and going for the KO when you don't have to certainly impresses me even if the fighter doesn't get it.

    Another factor is lack of hard punches. Some guys exclusively stick and move and never venture more than a hard shot here and there. This minimizes risk but again, it's boring. There's not going to be much of a reward for this other than a snoozer, points win, if that.

    I also don't care for guys who tie up their opponent anytime they are on the inside. Some exciting stuff happens on the inside but these fighters tend to rob the viewer of that. This also shows a lack of skill. And guys who hold a lot are just flat-out boring. No two ways about it to me.

    Low punch output is another one. I'm not saying 100 punches a round but damn. I'd prefer more than 10, too.

    So we have these 5 factors for determing boring fighters.

    Let's take Erik Morales

    1. Lack of KOS over a long period. In his heyday, this wasn't much of a problem for El Terrible. He was usually a fight or two from a KO regularly but in his later years, he did go a considerable time without a KO. So I give him a B grade here.

    2. Failure to Press the KO- I remember El Terrible going after guys like Paulie Ayala and Wayne McCullough with everything he had until the final bell, trying to get the KO even though he didn't. A for Morales here.

    3. Lack of Hard punches- Morales always worked behind a good jab but I never saw him fighter where he didn't unleash big rights and lefts. He gets an A here as well.

    4. Tying up the opponent- Morales loved a scrap and rarely tied guys up but he did a few times and so I'll give him a B here.

    5. Low Punch Output- I never recall Morales not throwing his share of shots even in his later years. A


    With 3 As and 2 Bs, I give El Terrible a solid A on Passing the Not-Boring Test.

    How about you guys? What makes a fighter boring for you?

    #2
    Andrade can be a good case study.

    Comment


      #3
      Running and hugging

      Comment


        #4
        There are a number of factors that have to compound on one another for a fighter to be considered "boring." IMO.

        For instance, not having a lot of power isn't enough to be boring by itself. There are several fighters with low knockout ratios but are still high-volume fighters who are often in all-action fights. Josh Warrington is the one who comes to mind most easily out of currently-active fighters.

        Being low-volume and cautious might be another sign of being "boring" but even then that might not be enough if a fighter does carry power. Some of the biggest punchers in the sport like Wilder and Wlad Klitschko match this description but nobody calls them boring when they land a huge shot that knocks their opponent flat.

        Even if a fighter's low-volume without power, if they have a sense of flair and showmanship or a big personality then you can't really call them boring. Look at Tyson Fury or Pernell Whitaker, both typically not huge punchers, not massive amounts of output from them with both being very defense-oriented, but both know how to still put on a show and keep the crowd engaged with showboating. Also look at Mayweather and late-era Hopkins, neither guy has huge power, both guys are defense-first and pick their shots, but everybody and their dog bought Mayweather's PPVs because of his bad-guy persona and everyone rooted for Hopkins because of his extraordinary run at world title honours at an advanced age - sometimes it's enough to just have a big personality or a great story.

        You have to compound everything together. If a guy's defense-first, doesn't carry a ton of power, doesn't throw a lot of punches and also has no flair for showmanship and doesn't have a particularly interesting personality and doesn't represent any kind of compelling narrative, then it's fine to call him boring IMO. For me the epitome of this is someone like Sakio Bika.
        Tony Trick-Pony Tony Trick-Pony likes this.

        Comment


          #5
          Bernard Hopkins
          Tony Trick-Pony Tony Trick-Pony likes this.

          Comment


            #6
            Originally posted by The plunger man View Post
            Bernard Hopkins
            One of the worst boxers I have ever seen. Never warmed up to him even in his days.

            Comment


              #7
              Originally posted by BoxingIsGreat View Post

              One of the worst boxers I have ever seen. Never warmed up to him even in his days.
              Only on this garbage forum can you have someone look at a living legend like Hopkins and have them call him "one of the worst boxers I have ever seen." Absolute clown show.

              Comment


                #8
                Originally posted by Scopedog View Post

                Only on this garbage forum can you have someone look at a living legend like Hopkins and have them call him "one of the worst boxers I have ever seen." Absolute clown show.
                Nope. It's the truth. People actually overrate average boxers like Hopkins on this site. I dreaded cards that included him on HBO.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Shawn Porter. Sloppy and inaccurate despite being a high action guy who always brings it

                  Mikey Garcia. Fights with indifference. No passion at all. Perhaps his father and brother forced boxing onto him

                  Brandon Rios. Awful defense is a lack of skill and I admire skill

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Inaccuracy is the biggest sin

                    we all want to see great punches. It’s why highlight reels cover the big shots

                    guys who aren’t inaccurate don’t deliver great punches as often

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    X
                    TOP