Let's all agree now. Calzaghe is an ATG.

[AntDawg]

I guess Jermaine Taylor is a ATG since he beat Hopkins twice??

[S A M U R A I]

ugh.. Calzaghe wasn't moving up ten pounds in weight to fight Nard.

No, 7 pounds. Close enough, especially as kelly walks around at over 170 anyway (approx. 174).

And stop making excuses. Pavlik will never be on Hopkins' level at any weight.



| |

[S.G.]

Hopkins beat Calzaghe and Taylor both times!

i've rated Joe as a HOF'er and borderline ATG before that fight even though

[The Hammer]

I guess Jermaine Taylor is a ATG since he beat Hopkins twice??

Jermain never beat anyone else.

Calzaghe defeated prime Kessler, who had two world titles. Joe schooling of Lacy was similar to Hopkins' schooling of Pavlik last night.

Although Joe fought a few bums along the way in his title defenses (so did B-Hop), Joe also defeated some some good fighters such as Brewer, Mitchell, and Eubank.

[fightingfigs]

I guess Jermaine Taylor is a ATG since he beat Hopkins twice??

Exactly, And Pavlik beat Jermaine twice. Styles makes fights

[BLOODGOD]

This thread is full of calzhage's nuts.... correct me if i'm wrong... peace

[BattlingNelson]

Sorry Man but just because the Judges said he won doesn't mean that it was true. Hopkjins lost because of the white boy line. They punished him for that. Thats why he learned his lesson conducted himself in a more intelligent manner agains Pavilik. In my neighborhood and school of thought. When two men fight , when one has been knocked down, wobbled, and cut while their opponent has felt neither of these circumstances we consider the one who wasn't knocked down, cut or wobbled, the winner.Also despite the decision, after the fight even during the fight i would've rther been Hopkins. If getting your face ****e up and brain rocked entails victory to you, then your an idiot and I'd fight you anyday.

No offense but this post is ******.

This aint Kimbo Slice fighting on the street. It's a boxing match with rules.

[Mr. Philadel]

No offense but this post is ******.

This aint Kimbo Slice fighting on the street. It's a boxing match with rules.

[WESS]

So Calzaghe fought the worst fight in a long time against Hopkins but still won.

Hopkins followed the loss with a schooling of the young, favoured undefeated Pavlik.

Even the yanks must now acknowledge. Joe Calzaghe is an ALL-TIME-GREAT!

sorry no. Not taking away. but dont give anything either. Hop last night wasnt the same fighter I watched L too JT, and JC. Even when he beat Winky and Tarver. Hop last night was a something on anther level. meaning His age was not a factor and was more active in ONE round VS Pav than he was in the entire fights of JC and JT.

That is the only reason I dont give anything to either JC or JT..... Not only that neither guy "BEAT' Hopkins just slightly out worked him. Joe being the worse of the two. JT beat Hop more than Joe did

Anyway HOP is a BAMF'in ATG. Joe's lucky if hes gets in the HOF...... ATG? GOOOOOOAAAAAAAALLLLLLLLLLLL....................... ...

I mean NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO O!!!!!! Not in this life time

[revs1227]

i have no idea how anyone can agrue b hop one .. calzaghe did 2 b hop what b hop did 2 kelly he solved him and took him apart