Tyson, Holyfield and Lewis.

[winky's right]

H2H (against others):....... 1. Lewis 2. Tyson 3. Holyfield
H2H (against each other):..1. Lewis 2. Holyfield 3. Tyson
P4P:...............................1. Lewis 2. Holyfield 3. Tyson

[Joeyzagz]

Lol, I just gave my opinion on who I think would win at their peaks like the thread starter asked.

It matters what people think, If everyone thinks someone is great it don't matter.

If we were comparing guys who never fought before, like Ali and Louis, then an opinion would matter.

Both Tyson and Evan fought Lennox in real life and could not defeat him. That's a fact.

[Holtol]

If we were comparing guys who never fought before, like Ali and Louis, then an opinion would matter.

Both Tyson and Evan fought Lennox in real life and could not defeat him. That's a fact.

Opinion still matters when we are talking about who would beat who at their peak. I know you know better then to say that Lewis beat a peak Holyfield and Tyson. Have you been drinking tonight Zags ?

[TBear]

May I change my answer every few days as the mood hits me? Tough one!

[The Surgeon]

If we were comparing guys who never fought before, like Ali and Louis, then an opinion would matter.

Both Tyson and Evan fought Lennox in real life and could not defeat him. That's a fact.

Com'on Zags, we talking PRIMES here. Tyson was what 15 years outta his prime when Lewis got him? Evander was also past his best. So infact the question is a matter of opinion

[Stallone60]

For me if Tyson never went to prison and fought his 91 clash with holyfield he would of won back the title then fought lewis and beat him also. Holyfield and lewis have a better record in the 90's and beat a shell of the great mike tyson. for me its tyson, holyfield, lewis.

[beez721]

If we were comparing guys who never fought before, like Ali and Louis, then an opinion would matter.

Both Tyson and Evan fought Lennox in real life and could not defeat him. That's a fact.

tyson and holyfield were damaged goods when lewis fought them. they couldnt fight at a pace anymore. prime tyson and holyfield would have eaten lewis up with there combination punching

[bojangles1987]

I've never been THAT sold on Tyson's greatness. He was a great fighter, but:

1. Holyfield
2. Lewis
3. Tyson

Holyfield should be the clear number one IMO, Lewis and Tyson is a tougher choice, but I think a prime Lewis beats a prime Tyson. Bring up his chin if you want, but he didn't get knocked out in big fights.

[The Surgeon]

I've never been THAT sold on Tyson's greatness. He was a great fighter, but:

1. Holyfield
2. Lewis
3. Tyson

Holyfield should be the clear number one IMO, Lewis and Tyson is a tougher choice, but I think a prime Lewis beats a prime Tyson. Bring up his chin if you want, but he didn't get knocked out in big fights.

Lewis had a better chin than given credit for but Tyson hit like a truck and could end him.

I just rate Tyson so highly on what my eyes seen him do but i understand his record falls short of truely great

[Toney616]

Who is greatest of the 3? I've seen them in every order possible, so I want to get posters opinions on this, poll to vote.

How do peak for peak match-ups with each of them go?

H2H Prime:
Holyfield
Tyson
Lewis

Im using the Holyfield from Bowe I, The Tyson who fought Ribalta and the Lewis who fought Mercer