Who are top 3 fighters for each division?

[DeepSleep]

I prefer to only rank fighter's in only one division (Ex. I only rank Ray Robinson at WW to simplify things on my brain).

Also I give a slight preference to how a fighter would fare head to head over his accomplishments.

Here's my first four divisions:

Heavyweight:
1. Muhammad Ali
2. Joe Louis
3. Larry Holmes

Crusierweight:
1. Evander Holyfield
2. Jean Marc Mormeck
3. Carlos De Leon

Light Heavyweight:
1. Ezzard Charles
2. Archie Moore
3. Michael Spinks

Super Middleweight:
1. Roy Jones Jr.
2. James Toney
3. Joe Calzaghe

[frankenfrank]

Are u serious?

Vitali Klitschko and David Tua in a top 3 ATG HW list? Please explain?

There are not many fighters who could have stopped them or even last the distance against them.
Maybe I should have put a prime George Foreman instead of Tua.

[NChristo]

There are not many fighters who could have stopped them or even last the distance against them.
Maybe I should have put a prime George Foreman instead of Tua.

Liston, Peak Bowe, Lewis and maybe Holyfield all have a decent chance of beating them both.

Sure a argument can be made for quite a few more aswell.

[frankenfrank]

Liston, Peak Bowe, Lewis and maybe Holyfield all have a decent chance of beating them both.

Sure a argument can be made for quite a few more aswell.

Liston was stopped twice by a young Ali. Put Tua in there instead of him , he will get rid of Patterson just as fast , and at least last the distance against Ali.
Foreman was KO'd by Ali because Dundee fetched the ropes especially for Ali's tactics . Lewis was humiliated and stopped by Rahman and McCall , Holyfield was stopped by Bowe , and used his head against many as well as clinches , and Bowe ducked almost every elite fighter of his time.

[NChristo]

Liston was stopped twice by a young Ali. Put Tua in there instead of him , he will get rid of Patterson just as fast , and at least last the distance against Ali.
Foreman was KO'd by Ali because Dundee fetched the ropes especially for Ali's tactics . Lewis was humiliated and stopped by Rahman and McCall , Holyfield was stopped by Bowe , and used his head against many as well as clinches , and Bowe ducked almost every elite fighter of his time.

They was still all more skilled, I would favour any of them over Tua and Vitali.

[BigStereotype]

HW : Vitali Klitschko , Muhammad Ali , David Tua
CW : Evander Holyfield , Michael Spinks , Michael Moorer
LHW : Michael Spinks , Rocky Marciano , Ezzard Charles
SMW : Joe Calzaghe , James Toney , Roy Jones
MW : Marvin Hagler , Sam Langford , Carlos Monzon
LMW : Mike McCallum , Julian Jackson , Ray Robinson
WW : Ray Robinson , Ray Leonard , Young Peter Jackson
LWW : Manny Pacquiao , Roberto Duran , Oscar Delahoya
LW : Henry Armstrong , Julio Cesar Chavez , Hector Camacho


may be wrong about Camacho , but I did not want to think more than I already did.

This list is a joke. You have Vitali as the greatest heavyweight ever and David Tua above everyone who deserves to be in this list. Please get out.

[StarshipTrooper]

Liston was stopped twice by a young Ali. Put Tua in there instead of him , he will get rid of Patterson just as fast , and at least last the distance against Ali.

The same way he got rid of Chris Byrd?

Foreman was KO'd by Ali because Dundee fetched the ropes especially for Ali's tactics . Lewis was humiliated and stopped by Rahman and McCall , Holyfield was stopped by Bowe , and used his head against many as well as clinches , and Bowe ducked almost every elite fighter of his time.

Okay, it's established: You are well and truly ******ed

Poet

[Joey Giardello]

Heavyweight
1.Ali
2.Louis
3.Marciano

Cruiserweight
1.Holyfield
2.Haye
3.Qawi

Light Heavyweight
1.Spinks
2.Charles
3.Moore

Super Middleweight
1.Calzaghe
2.Jones Jr
3.Eubank

Middleweight
1.Monzon
2.Ketchel
3.Hagler

Jr Middleweight
1.Trinidad
2.Hearns
3.Norris

Welterweight
1.Robinson
2.Leonard
3.Armstrong

Jr Welterweight
1.Pryor
2.Chavez
3.Cervantes

Lightweight
1.Duran
2.Whitaker
3.Leonard

Super Featherweight
1.Mayweather
2.Arguello
3.Nelson

Featherweight
1.Sanchez
2.Pep
3.Pedroza

Super Bantamweight
1.Gomez
2.Morales
3.Fenech

Bantamweight
1.Zarate
2.Jofre
3.Olivares

Flyweight
1.Wilde
2.Perez
3.Canto

[mickey malone]

Heavyweight

Joe Louis
Muhummad Ali
Larry Holmes

Cruiserweight

Evander Holyfield
David Haye
Johnny Nelson

Light Heavyweight

Ezzard Charles
Gene Tunney
Archie Moore

Super Middleweight

Roy Jones Jr
Joe Calzaghe
James Toney

Middleweight

Harry Greb
Carlos Monzon
Marvin Hagler

Light Middleweight

Mike McCallum
Thomas Hearns
Wilfred Benitez

Welterweight

Ray Robinson
Henry Armstrong
Ray Leonard

Light Welterweight

Barney Ross
Julio Cesar Chavez
Nicolino Locche

Lightweight

Benny Leonard
Roberto Duran
Joe Gans

Super Featherweight

Alexis Arguello
Floyd Mayweather jr
Manny Pacquiao

Featherweight

Willie Pep
Sandy Saddler
Salvador Sanchez

Super Bantamweight

Wilfredo Gomez
Jeff Fenech
Eric Morales

Bantamweight

Eder Jofre
Ruben Olivares
Al Brown

Super Flyweight

Kaosai Galaxy
Gilberto Roman
Jiro Watanabe

Flyweight

Jimmy Wilde
Pascal Perez
Rinty Monaghan

Light Flyweight

Jung Koo Chang
Yu Myung Woo
Michael Carbajal

Straw Weight

Ricardo Lopez
Ivan Calderon
Ratanapol Sor Vorapin

[HaglerSteelChin]

BUMP: This will help add the votes each week.