Who are top 3 fighters for each division?

[HaglerSteelChin]

Who do you rate as the top 3 fighter for each division? i know there are now 17 divisions and that means 51 fighters to choose. I will start with the 6 highest divsions. BTW, i am not using the point system that BS did with their system.


Heavyweight 1-Ali 2-Louis 3-Langford

Cruiser 1-Holyfield 2-Deleon 3-O'Neil Bell

Light heavyweight 1-E.Charles 2-M.Spinks 3-Archie Moore

Super Middleweight 1-Roy Jones jr. 2-Joe Calzaghe 3-Steve Collins

Middleweight 1-Sugar Ray Robinson 2-Harry Greb 3-Carlos Monzon

Junior Middlweight 1-Thomas Hearns 2-Winky Wright 3-Terry Norris

[NChristo]

Heavyweight- Joe Louis, Muhammad Ali, Jack Johnson

Light Heavyweight - Archie Moore, Ezzard Charles, Michael Spinks

Middleweight - Harry Greb, Ray Robinson, Carlos Monzon

Welterweight - Ray Robinson, Henry Armstrong, Ray Leonard

Lightweight - Joe Gans, Roberto Duran, Benny Leonard

Flyweight - Jimmy Wilde, Fidel Lebarba, Miguel Canto

Featherweight - Willie Pep, Sandy Saddler, Henry Armstrong

Bantamweight - Eder Jofre, Panama Al Brown, Ruben Olivares

Alot of names could be changed on there but that's my list :P.

[sonnyboyx2]

Heavyweight - Ali, Louis, Dempsey

Cruiserweight - Holyfield, DeLeon, J.C.Gomez

Light-heavyweight - Moore, Spinks, Charles

Super-middleweight - Jones Jr. Calzaghe, Chong-Pal Park.

middleweight - Robinson, Monzon, Hagler.

Light-Middleweight - Heanrs, McCallum, Jackson.

Welterweight - Robinson, Leonard, Armstrong.

Lightweight - Duran, B.Leonard, Whitaker.

Featherweight - Pacquiao, Arguello, Pep

Bantamweight - Olivares, Brown, Jofre

Flyweight - Wilde, Perez, Lopez.

[frankenfrank]

HW : Vitali Klitschko , Muhammad Ali , David Tua
CW : Evander Holyfield , Michael Spinks , Michael Moorer
LHW : Michael Spinks , Rocky Marciano , Ezzard Charles
SMW : Joe Calzaghe , James Toney , Roy Jones
MW : Marvin Hagler , Sam Langford , Carlos Monzon
LMW : Mike McCallum , Julian Jackson , Ray Robinson
WW : Ray Robinson , Ray Leonard , Young Peter Jackson
LWW : Manny Pacquiao , Roberto Duran , Oscar Delahoya
LW : Henry Armstrong , Julio Cesar Chavez , Hector Camacho


may be wrong about Camacho , but I did not want to think more than I already did.

[HaglerSteelChin]

Super Bantamweight 1-Wilfredo Gomez 2-Manny Pacquiao 3-Erik Morales
Bantamweight 1-Eder Joffre 2-Manuel Ortiz 3-Panama Brown
Super Flyweight 1-Khaosai Galaxy 2-Masomori Tokuyama 3-J. Tapia
Flyweight 1-Jimmy Wilde 2-Pascual Perez 3-Pancho Villa(i know he beat wilde but looking at overall success in FW.

Junior Flyweight 1-Jung Koo Chang 2-Michael Carbajal 3-Yoko Gushiken
Straweight 1-Ricardo Lopez 2-Ivan Calderon 3-Rontanapol Sar Vorapin)(sp?) Too tired to google or boxrec

Wil finish 126-147 next time but obviously expect names as SRR, Armstrong, both leonards, Gans, Duran

[Southpaw Great]

HW : Vitali Klitschko , Muhammad Ali , David Tua
CW : Evander Holyfield , Michael Spinks , Michael Moorer
LHW : Michael Spinks , Rocky Marciano , Ezzard Charles
SMW : Joe Calzaghe , James Toney , Roy Jones
MW : Marvin Hagler , Sam Langford , Carlos Monzon
LMW : Mike McCallum , Julian Jackson , Ray Robinson
WW : Ray Robinson , Ray Leonard , Young Peter Jackson
LWW : Manny Pacquiao , Roberto Duran , Oscar Delahoya
LW : Henry Armstrong , Julio Cesar Chavez , Hector Camacho


may be wrong about Camacho , but I did not want to think more than I already did.

Are u serious?

Vitali Klitschko and David Tua in a top 3 ATG HW list? Please explain?

[Joeyzagz]

Heavyweight: Lennox Beat everyone he ever faced

Cruiserweight: Marciano Beat everyone he ever faced

LHW: Roy Jones- Dominated

SMW: Calzaghe Beat everyone he ever faced


MW: Hagler- Dominated Division

P4P: Floyd Mayweather Beat everyone he ever faced


WW: Sugar Ray Robinson Beat everyone he ever faced at WW



LW: Duran Dominated

FW: Willie Pep 200+ wins only 10 losses

[HaglerSteelChin]

Welterweight 1-Sugar Ray Robinson 2-Henry Armstrong 3-Ray Leonard

Junior Weltereight 1- Aaron Pryor 2-Julio Cesar Chavez 3-Antonio Cervantes

*hard to pick although Chavez loss to DLH and was being schooled by Taylor until the last second stoppage he had great wins here, DLH was great at 140 but not enough fights, Cervantes loss to a 17 year old wizard but is one of the best at that weight, Kostya high but 2 losses here, Pryor pretty made his name on one division with or without magic bottles.

Lightweight 1- Benny Leonard 2-Joe Gans 3-Roberto Duran

Super Featherweight 1-Floyd Mayweather Jr. 2-Flash Elorde 3-Hiroshi Koboyashi

Featherweight 1- Willie Pepp 2-Sandy Saddler 3-Salvador Sanchez

* I had Attel and Armstrong slightly below Sanchez at FW. Armstrong beat Ambers, Ross, and Garcia at weights north from FW and Attel had more defenses than Salvador but i felt Sanchez had the stiffer competition. He also fought in a modern era with more international competition. It would be difficult to have any list of all three guys being Pre-1950.

[StarshipTrooper]

Are u serious?

Vitali Klitschko and David Tua in a top 3 ATG HW list? Please explain?

Not to mention listing Marciano as a Light-Heavyweight

Poet

[StarshipTrooper]

Old-School Eight:

Heavyweight: 1. Muhammed Ali, 2. Joe Louis, 3. Jack Johnson
Light-Heavyweight: 1. Ezzard Charles, 2. Archie Moore, 3. Gene Tunney
Middleweight: 1. Ray Robinson, 2. Bob Fitzsimmons, 3. Sam Langford
Welterweight: 1. Ray Robinson, 3. Henry Armstrong, 3. Ray Leonard
Lightweight: 1. Roberto Duran, 2. Benny Leonard, 3. Pernell Whitaker
Featherweight: 1. Alexis Arguello, 2. Willie Pepp, 3. Sandy Sadler
Bantamweight: 1. Eder Jofre, 03. Jeff Chandler, 3. Pete Herman
Flyweight: 1. Pascual Perez, 2. Miguel Canto, 3. Jimmy Wilde