1986 Mike McCallum vs........

[Southpaw16BF]

How does fare against these fighters at 154lb.

-2004 Winky Wright
-1991 Terry Norris
-2007 Floyd Mayweather
-1984 Thomas Hearns
-1982 Tony Ayala Jr

[Joey Giardello]

How does fare against these fighters at 154lb.

-2004 Winky Wright
-1991 Terry Norris
-2007 Floyd Mayweather
-1984 Thomas Hearns
-1982 Tony Ayala Jr

Besides hearns he beats all of them

[oldgringo]

I'd favor him against everyone but Tommy. He'd have a real shot at that one too.

[Jamal Perkins]

Mccallum vs a 1991 Terry Norris would have been a nice match up....if Norris won that fight he would've imo...graduated into a much better fighter...but I can't see it happening...and see a brutal knockout loss...Norris could be very indisciplined

[markusmod]

Besides hearns he beats all of them

I agree with Joey.

[Inter Beer]

I think Floyd maybe wins on decision, Hearns same or late tko
I think he beats the others. He was a really top fighter.
Him v Hagler would have been a glorious scrap

[billeau2]

How does fare against these fighters at 154lb.

-2004 Winky Wright
-1991 Terry Norris
-2007 Floyd Mayweather
-1984 Thomas Hearns
-1982 Tony Ayala Jr

Lol. I can't argue with the consensus here. Wright hates to get down and dirty, preferring to play peekaboo at a nice distance and pick apart his opponents. Mccallum is on him like white on rice. Norris was a question mark because I haven't followed him much. So no comment. Floyd gets beaten to a pulp... Average fighters at this weight gave him a time of it. Hearns is the exception... Can he beat Mccallum? well... its an either/or. If Hearns can hurt with one of the best jabs in the game, he wins it. But Mccallum could crash the gate on Tommy. Tommy wasn't weak anywhere, but his chin was not his greatest asset. Mccallum was not a KO puncher, but he could crack. Tony Ayala? Tony who?

[them_apples]

How does fare against these fighters at 154lb.

-2004 Winky Wright
-1991 Terry Norris
-2007 Floyd Mayweather
-1984 Thomas Hearns
-1982 Tony Ayala Jr

Tommy before his chin got cracked by Hagler and he bulked up is the only one with a fair shot. In all honesty though, Think Mccallum beats them all.

[them_apples]

I think Floyd maybe wins on decision, Hearns same or late tko
I think he beats the others. He was a really top fighter.
Him v Hagler would have been a glorious scrap

You think Floyd decisions him?? lol what are you reasons for this? Floyd had 2 fights at 154, both against former Welters, both fights he didn't have any easy time - some even think he lost to Oscar. Hagler wasn't on the list but that would've been good because Hagler was adaptable and could turn it into a slugfest possibly.

[Nash out]

You think Floyd decisions him?? lol what are you reasons for this? Floyd had 2 fights at 154, both against former Welters, both fights he didn't have any easy time - some even think he lost to Oscar. Hagler wasn't on the list but that would've been good because Hagler was adaptable and could turn it into a slugfest possibly.

McCallum was nothing special. His very controversial SD win over domestic level Herol Graham sums him up. Sure he beat Watson and Collins, both good wins, but neither would be close to top 10 Mayweather wins. Talk about overrating these old guys! LMFAO! Nash out.