"Aye test doe" If thats the criteria for p4p then how is Boots/Ortiz/Spence not above Crawford p4p?

[kushking]

What you're doing is mixing arguments from disparate sources to fit whatever weird narrative you're shilling.

I've never claimed the eye test is why Crawford was a P4P fighter. It was always based on his accomplishments.

There are very few multi-weight lineal champions in boxing right now, and the ones to accomplish that feat didn't do so by accident.

Spence has been doing something Bud hasn't at ww last few years(trying to fight the best & collecting belts which is why he fought Brook before he was as washed as the 1 Bud fought)

(what Bud accomplished half a decade ago at a weight someone his size/reach had tons of advantages, should not be relevant to welterweight,but even then the opponents he beat warent good except for Postal/Gamboa)

[TernceBudCharlo]

Spence has been doing something Bud hasn't at ww last few years(trying to fight the best & collecting belts which is why he fought Brook before he was as washed as the 1 Bud fought)

(what Bud accomplished half a decade ago at a weight someone his size/reach had tons of advantages, should not be relevant to welterweight,but even then the opponents he beat warent good except for Postal/Gamboa)

Cut that bull**** out, everyone knew Brook was damaged goods from the Glolovkin fight and that it was his first time trying to make the cut to 147 in a long time. You think Bud hasn't fought anyone as good as Ducky Garcia or Danny Garcia? Embarrassing. Bud's resume destroys Spence's every day.

[TernceBudCharlo]

The hate for this man is one of the most vile, evil, nauseating things I have ever seen in a lifetime of watching boxing

[ShoulderRoll]

Going just by the eye test Boots is the best welterweight in the world.

[i love boxing]

crawford has accomplished more then all of them combined

[ShoulderRoll]

crawford has accomplished more then all of them combined

We're taking accomplishments out of it. Talking strictly about just the eye test here.

[ippo]

I still have Canelo as pfp #1 its too obvious, he is #1 based on who he fought and how he has looked. You can look good fighting sub par comp, its who you beat that matters. Porter is a good fighter, but it's obvious he has declined and lost about every big fight he's been in.

[TernceBudCharlo]

I still have Canelo as pfp #1 its too obvious, he is #1 based on who he fought and how he has looked. You can look good fighting sub par comp, its who you beat that matters. Porter is a good fighter, but it's obvious he has declined and lost about every big fight he's been in.

The main reason we know Canelo can't be #1 is that if Bud was Canelo, he already would have fought Andrade and Charlo now. Benavidez too.

[ippo]

The main reason we know Canelo can't be #1 is that if Bud was Canelo, he already would have fought Andrade and Charlo now. Benavidez too.

Lets see if he actually signs with someone else. He pretty much avoided the top guys in the division by resigning with top rank a few years ago. While everyone was beating the prime out of each other he was feasting on no hopers.

[i love boxing]

We're taking accomplishments out of it. Talking strictly about just the eye test here.

That is not how p4p works, it is based on accomplishments