Who deserves more criticism Calzaghe or Mayweather

[Dynamite Kid]

I know whats behind the numbers. Corrales, Castillo x2, De la Hoya, g.Hernandez, Judah, c.Hernandez, Chavez, Gatti, Hatton, Corley, N'Dou, Sosa. Mayweather has many quality wins in his career. Everybody is on Cotto's nuts or was on Margarito's nuts or William's nuts but Mayweather has fought much better comp than those guys. Has beaten HOF great fighters, good fighters and champions. He could even have an L against Castillo, and if you want to argue he lost that fight then he avenged it right away with a clearcut victory in a rematch.

Well you will know all the guys he faced were B class fighters. Not elite fighters.

Hopkins/Pacquiao are from the same era and they blitz his ass for competition level, and that mofo Floyd thinks he is better than Leonard and Robinson, and you have the audacity to think he gets criticized unfairly

Compared to other great fighters of his era his resume is poor.

[Sin City]

i think calzaghe does, too little too late should be the slogan for his career.

[ILLuminato]

Mayweather, he fought like a coward.

[RoyJonesJrp4pno1]

Well you will know all the guys he faced were B class fighters. Not elite fighters.

Hopkins/Pacquiao are from the same era and they blitz his ass for competition level, and that mofo Floyd thinks he is better than Leonard and Robinson, and you have the audacity to think he gets criticized unfairly

Compared to other great fighters of his era his resume is poor.

De la Hoya, Castillo, g Hernandez and Corrales are not A fighters? You have obviously never seen them guys fight. Go watch some fights and get some knowledge because if your going to hate on a great champion at least do it right.

What A fighters has Cotto, Margarito or Williams beaten? Mayweather has fought better comp than any of them guys he gets critisism for "ducking"

[Dan...]

Well you will know all the guys he faced were B class fighters. Not elite fighters.

Hopkins/Pacquiao are from the same era and they blitz his ass for competition level, and that mofo Floyd thinks he is better than Leonard and Robinson, and you have the audacity to think he gets criticized unfairly

Compared to other great fighters of his era his resume is poor.

You mean all the fighters on Floyd's resume are B class fighters?

Man, that is complete rubbish if that is what you are saying.

[Dynamite Kid]

De la Hoya, Castillo, g Hernandez and Corrales are not A fighters? You have obviously never seen them guys fight. Go watch some fights and get some knowledge because if your going to hate on a great champion at least do it right.

What A fighters has Cotto, Margarito or Williams beaten? Mayweather has fought better comp than any of them guys he gets critisism for "ducking"

What do you think?

DLH was not elite when Floyd fought him.

What chance do you think Castillo would have with Pernell Whitaker/Duran/Mosley at LW ? it would be a fcukin white wash. The dude is a level below that same as Chico.

Ive seen all them fight i can run thought it with you, if like?

[Dynamite Kid]

You mean all the fighters on Floyd's resume are B class fighters?

Man, that is complete rubbish if that is what you are saying.

Name me an elite fighter on his record.

They are B + at best.

[QUISQUEYA]

Well you will know all the guys he faced were B class fighters. Not elite fighters.

Hopkins/Pacquiao are from the same era and they blitz his ass for competition level, and that mofo Floyd thinks he is better than Leonard and Robinson, and you have the audacity to think he gets criticized unfairly

Compared to other great fighters of his era his resume is poor.

Tell me the prime elites that Pacquiao has beat in his run.

1) first fight with MAB (6 years ago)
2) Draw/win with JMM

What are the other Pac wins that you are touting? PLEASE.

Hopkins: Moved up and beat Tarver. What are the other wins where the opponent wasn't substantially above his best weights? let'as face it... BHop has feasted on smaller guys.

[QUISQUEYA]

Name me an elite fighter on his record.

They are B + at best.

Corrales was P4P #3, Hatton was P4P #8.

Are those elite?

And if Delahoya/Hatton are such ****ty opponents, remind me why Pacquiao is fighting them 2 years later.

[Dynamite Kid]

Tell me the prime elites that Pacquiao has beat in his run.

1) first fight with MAB (6 years ago)
2) Draw/win with JMM

What are the other Pac wins that you are touting? PLEASE.

Hopkins: Moved up and beat Tarver. What are the other wins where the opponent wasn't substantially above his best weights? let'as face it... BHop has feasted on smaller guys.

Im not going to get into this its commonsense. I know you wanna deflect the attention away from Floyd, because you cant come up with an elite fighter he has faced.

Should i make a poll on who has the better resume Pac/Hopkins or Floyd?