what wins meant more

[larryx]

floyd beating judah and balomir-the current lineal champ..and ex lineal champ

or cotto beating quintana-for a vacant belt-baldo couldnt afford
and an old mosley

[Flawless 2]

First option since Mosley ducked Mayweather and Carlos Q was a nobody at that stage

[larryx]

First option since Mosley ducked Mayweather and Carlos Q was a nobody at that stage

vote my friend..you cant tell cotto fans that
mayweather beat both the current and ex lineal champs back to back

cotto beat quintana for a vacant belt
and an old mosley

[Dice]

floyd beating judah and balomir-the current lineal champ..and ex lineal champ

or cotto beating quintana-for a vacant belt-baldo couldnt afford
and an old mosley

Floyds wins meant more on paper but Cotto's wins really mean more. Quintana is underrated and even if he did get ko-ed in one round by P, he still beat him in the first fight and Carlos would kill Baldomir.

Mosley is old but Judah is just ******, I cant defend him no more after that Clottey fight, Mosley woulda beat Judah if the fight would have stood and Cotto beat Judah anyways

HOWEVER...................COTTO STAND NO CHANCE AGAINST MAYWEATHER

[TheManchine]

First option since Mosley ducked Mayweather and Carlos Q was a nobody at that stage

Mosley never "ducked" Mayweather

you are going to post about this toothache but its complete bull****

[deevel79]

Aside from who held belts/titles at the time the fights took place, Quintana and Mosley were more credible opponents than Baldomir and Judah. Mosley beats both them. Lets not forget that Cotto destroyed Zab and KO'd him. Zab was able to win 4-5 rounds against Floyd and even dropped him.

[Flawless 2]

Aside from who held belts/titles at the time the fights took place, Quintana and Mosley were more credible opponents than Baldomir and Judah. Mosley beats both them.

Now yes, at the time no

[larryx]

Aside from who held belts/titles at the time the fights took place, Quintana and Mosley were more credible opponents than Baldomir and Judah. Mosley beats both them. Lets not forget that Cotto destroyed Zab and KO'd him. Zab was able to win 4-5 rounds against Floyd and even dropped him.

after 2 low blows..lets not forget floyd destroyed judah and was about to ko hum until that brutal low blow that resulted in a riot

[larryx]

Aside from who held belts/titles at the time the fights took place, Quintana and Mosley were more credible opponents than Baldomir and Judah. Mosley beats both them. Lets not forget that Cotto destroyed Zab and KO'd him. Zab was able to win 4-5 rounds against Floyd and even dropped him.

how can quintana be more credible than judah or baldo..when he was unproven???

[deevel79]

how can quintana be more credible than judah or baldo..when he was unproven???

Beating Williams >>>> Anything Judah or Baldo has done since.