Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

How many active fighters have two quality wins?

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    #41
    Originally posted by RJJ-94-02=GOAT View Post
    It is subjective but not being bias at all just looking at the facts.

    AJ’s best two wins are Wlad and Povetkin right? Wlad 41 and 18 months inactive and Povetkin 39. Neither were world champions when he fought them. That’s not subjective that’s factual.

    They’re respectable wins but neither qualify as quality wins when you put them into context.
    Interesting that you assumed I was referring to Joshua... Maybe because you acknowledge your own bias?

    Povetkin, Parker and Wlad were all amongst the the top rated guys in the division and had as good or better resumes than the likes of Wilder and Juarez who you've mentioned.

    Comment


      #42
      Originally posted by Apollo7 View Post
      Interesting that you assumed I was referring to Joshua... Maybe because you acknowledge your own bias?

      Povetkin, Parker and Wlad were all amongst the the top rated guys in the division and had as good or better resumes than the likes of Wilder and Juarez who you've mentioned.
      Who else would it be? I said Santa Cruz and Frampton were good suggestions.

      Wilder was an undefeated world champion who had made 10 consecutive defences.

      I never listed Juarez as a quality win either, I said it was a solid win of Linares’ who was a quality win for Loma.

      AJ simply doesn’t have a quality win. Parker is his probably his best win as he was an undefeated world champion coming in but do you really think that’s comparable to Fury beating Klitschko or Wilder on the road?

      Comment


        #43
        Originally posted by KTFOKING View Post
        Brook was definitely a quality win. People now try to knock that win for some reason but Brook fought well and it was competitive until he got broken down.

        If you put Porter up there, then Garcia essentially fought him even and was tight with Thurman as well. I would put Spence up there with two quality wins.
        I just think the weight issue was a notable factor.

        Spence probably does deserve to be on the list.

        Comment


          #44
          Terence Crawford has multiple quality wins

          Comment


            #45
            Originally posted by TernceBudCharlo View Post
            Terence Crawford has multiple quality wins
            Who?

            Huge Crawford fan but he doesn’t IMO.

            Postol is probably his best.

            Comment


              #46
              Teofimo Lopez - Richard Commey and Lomachenko

              Comment


                #47
                Originally posted by RJJ-94-02=GOAT View Post
                Who?

                Huge Crawford fan but he doesn’t IMO.

                Postol is probably his best.
                Mean Machine, Benavidez, Horn, Indongo, Diaz, Gamboa, Dulorme, Burns

                Comment


                  #48
                  Originally posted by RJJ-94-02=GOAT View Post
                  Who else would it be? I said Santa Cruz and Frampton were good suggestions.

                  Wilder was an undefeated world champion who had made 10 consecutive defences.

                  I never listed Juarez as a quality win either, I said it was a solid win of Linares’ who was a quality win for Loma.

                  AJ simply doesn’t have a quality win. Parker is his probably his best win as he was an undefeated world champion coming in but do you really think that’s comparable to Fury beating Klitschko or Wilder on the road?
                  Frampton, Santa Cruz and Joshua were all mentioned yet you assumed I was referring Joshua. You tell me why.

                  Parker was a champ and top 5 in the division. How is that not a quality win? Why should Parker be considered a lesser win than Wilder?

                  Klitschko was a proven champ and had only recently lost to Fury (same as Fury).

                  Povetkin is also clearly a quality HW win looking at resumes and rankings

                  Try being impartial and not a fanboy. Talking about Wlad and Pov's age when Ortiz was how old?

                  Comment


                    #49
                    Originally posted by TernceBudCharlo View Post
                    Mean Machine, Benavidez, Horn, Indongo, Diaz, Gamboa, Dulorme, Burns
                    Nah...

                    Gamboa and Postol are the only guys I’d even consider tbh.

                    Comment


                      #50
                      Originally posted by Apollo7 View Post
                      Frampton, Santa Cruz and Joshua were all mentioned yet you assumed I was referring Joshua. You tell me why.

                      Parker was a champ and top 5 in the division. How is that not a quality win? Why should Parker be considered a lesser win than Wilder?

                      Klitschko was a proven champ and had only recently lost to Fury (same as Fury).

                      Povetkin is also clearly a quality HW win looking at resumes and rankings

                      Try being impartial and not a fanboy. Talking about Wlad and Pov's age when Ortiz was how old?
                      Because I agreed with the other two and not AJ. Are you f***ing slow or something?

                      HW has no depth. Being top 5 in that division doesn’t make it a top quality win.

                      I never listed Ortiz as a quality win so why bring him up. Like Povetkin he was near 40 and never won a world title. Good fighter but not a quality win.

                      Klitschko was 41, 18 months inactive, on the verge of retirement, was coming off a one sided loss and hadn’t won a fight in two years. All factual...

                      You’re clearly just an AJ fanboy who’s butt-hurt cause he ain’t worthy of making this list. Accusing people of being “bias” because they are making relevant points.

                      GTFOH you idiot...

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X
                      TOP