Official bad scorecard thread 2020.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Gonna make an official thread where we can log bad decisions scorecards and also the people responsible.

This way, we can look for patterns between certain judges, commissions etc.

Please post any scorecard you see this year that you felt was unjust or su****ious.

**Shoutout to The*******Days** who came up with this idea.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

1. James Kinney scoring Smith-Hart 95-94 to Hart.

2. Alex Levin scoring Diaz-Farmer 115-113 Diaz.

3. Richard Green scoring Diaz-Farmer 115-113 Diaz.

4. Richard Green scoring Angulo-Sims Jr 95-94 to Sims Jr.

5. Don Ackerman scoring Rigondeaux-Solis 115-112 to Solis.

6. Chas Coakley scoring Mimoune-McKenna 97-93 to McKenna.

7. Kieran McCann scoring Mimoune-McKenna 96-94 to McKenna.

8. Marcus McDonnell scoring Mimoune-McKenna 96-94 to McKenna.

9. Chas Coakley scoring ****ens-Wood 95-95 a draw.

10. Rudy Barragan scoring Rocha-Solomon 100-89 to Rocha.

11. Max DeLuca scoring Rocha-Solomon 99-90 to Rocha.

12. Herb Santos scoring Martinez-Harris 118-109 to Martinez.

13. Dave Moretti scoring Gonzalez-Yafai 77-74 to Gonzalez at the time of the stoppage.

14. Juergen Billhardt, Alexander Plumanns and Ilhan H*m*vic giving Artur Szpilka a MD gift.

15. Tim Cheetham scoring Santillan-DeMarco 96-94 to Santillan.

16. Steve Weisfeld scoring Santillan-DeMarco 96-94 to Santillan

17. Dave Moretti scoring Santillan-DeMarco 95-95 a Draw.

18. Dave Moretti scoring Plania-Greer Jr 94-94 a Draw.

19. Patricia Morse Jarman scoring Collard-Kaminsky 58-56 to Kaminsky.

20. Dave Moretti scoring Franco-Maloney 114-113 to Franco.

21. Patricia Morse Jarman scoring Franco-Moloney 114-113 to Franco.

22. Frank Lombardi scoring Romero-Marinez 118-110 to Romero.

23. Glenn Feldman scoring Romero-Marinez 116-112 to Romero.

24. Don Trella scoring Romero-Marinez 115-113 to Romero.

25. Victor Loughlin scoring Cullen-Chelli 96-95 to Cullen.

26. Ian John Lewis scoring Cullen-Chelli 95-95 a Draw.

27. Victor Loughlin scoring Taylor-Persoon 98-93 to Taylor.

28. Steve Weisfeld scoring Ramirez-Postol 116-112 to Ramirez.

29. Lou Moret scoring Ugas-Ramos 117-111 to Ramos.

30. Zachary Young scoring Ugas-Ramos 115-113 to Ugas.

31. Edward Hernandez Sr scoring Ugas-Ramos 115-113 to Ugas.

32. Don Trella scoring Nyambayar-Breedy 115-111 to Breedy.

33. Joerg Milke scoring Briedis-Dorticos 114-114.

34. David Sutherland scoring Charlo-Derevyanchenko 118-110 to Charlo.

35. Don Ackerman scoring Nery-Alameda 118-110 to Nery.

36. Terry O’Connor scoring Ward-Essomba 88-84 to Ward.

37. Rudy Barragan and Lou Moret scoring Kroll-Santamaria 99-91 to Kroll.

38. Lou Moret scoring Magsayo-Hermosillo 96-94 to Hermosillo.

39. Rudy Barragan Magsayo-Hermosillo 100-90 to Magsayo.

40. Terry O’Connor scoring Ritson-Vazquez 117-111 to Ritson.

41. Michael Alexander scoring Ritson-Vazquez 115-113 to Ritson.

42. Julie Lederman scoring Lomachenko-Lopez 119-109 to Lopez.

43. Fernando Villarreal scoring Soto-Buitrago 119-109 to Soto.

44. Daniel Van De Wiele scoring McCarthy-Laggoune 114-114 a draw.

45. Yury Koptsev scoring Kambosos-Selby 118-110 to Kambosos.

46. John Latham scoring Joyce-Dubois 88-83 to Dubois at the time of the stoppage.

47. Ian John Lewis scoring Arthur-Yarde 117-111 to Yarde.

48. Javier Alvarez scoring Brooks-Delgado 57-55 to Brooks.

49. Marcus McDonnell scoring Marku-Stewart 76-76 a draw.

50. Don Ackermam scoring Hitchins-Mendez 97-93 to Mendez.

51. John Rupert scoring Ryder-Guy 96-94 to Ryder.

52. Don Trella scoring Rodriguez-Gaballo 116-112 to Gaballo.

53. John McKale scoring Rodriguez-Gaballo 115-113 to Gaballo.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Giving Farmer 5 rounds is shocking...

[JimmyValmer]

Callum Smith 116-112

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Callum Smith 116-112

This thread is for 2020.

That would certainly be on last year’s list.

[DuckAdonis]

Add the judge that scored 7 rounds for Roman

[TheMyspaceDayz]

Add the judge that scored 7 rounds for Roman

It was a close fight that could have gone either way.

[DuckAdonis]

It was a close fight that could have gone either way.

No it wasn't, clear win for Akhmadaliev. There's no way you can find 7 rounds Roman won. Try

[TheMyspaceDayz]

No it wasn't, clear win for Akhmadaliev. There's no way you can find 7 rounds Roman won. Try

I’m saying if someone did infact sit down and “try?to build a case then I do believe they could do it with some effort. He was landing short shots in between while a lot of MJ’s big flashy shots weren’t landing cleanly. That combined with the commentators siding with MJ braced me for a few of your types who think the fight was one sided. I’m not influenced by commentators... but at the same time you won’t find me arguing for a Roman win as I believe he loss a close fight. It just feels like an extreme stance to take when you’re calling for the head of a ref on this one.

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Add the judge that scored 7 rounds for Roman

Nah that was a very close fight. A lot of swing rounds.