Official bad scorecard thread 2020.

[famicommander]

Dave Moretti gave Chocolatito 77-74...and I'm struggling to find ONE round to give Yafai, let alone four.

Thoughts?

I think 0-2 rounds for Yafai is fair. No more.

[_Rexy_]

I was trying to find those cards last night. Had a feeling some moron would have it close. I thought Gonzalez won every round and only one or two rounds were even close.

You could maybe give Yafai two at the very most. Giving him 3 is incompetent.

Moretti is usually a decent judge but he’s still making the list.

Yeah, I had it 80-71 Everyone has an off night, but where in gods name are four rounds for Yafai? lol

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Yeah, I had it 80-71 Everyone has an off night, but where in gods name are four rounds for Yafai? lol

Yeah rounds 1 and 3 were relatively close. Every other round was a clear Gonzalez round, there’s no plausible explanation for giving Yafai any more than 2 rounds.

[asgarth]

havent seen it, but Szpilka was fighting tonight against journeyman Radchenko.
Apparently, Szpilka was knocked down in the third and beaten up throughout the fight and still got the decision.

[_Rexy_]

havent seen it, but Szpilka was fighting tonight against journeyman Radchenko.
Apparently, Szpilka was knocked down in the third and beaten up throughout the fight and still got the decision.

Anyone seen this fight yet?

[Mammoth]

Very, very controversial decision in Lomza, Poland. Former heavyweight Artur Szpilka (24-4, 16 KO's) returns to cruiserweight - hits the deck in the 3rd and was seemingly beat to the punch all night - takes a 10rd decision "win" over Serhiy Radchenko (7-6)

— Tim - Boxeo 拳闘 Boxen бокс มวย Boks 拳击 Box (@Hock1717)

[RJJ-94-02=GOAT]

Very, very controversial decision in Lomza, Poland. Former heavyweight Artur Szpilka (24-4, 16 KO's) returns to cruiserweight - hits the deck in the 3rd and was seemingly beat to the punch all night - takes a 10rd decision "win" over Serhiy Radchenko (7-6)

— Tim - Boxeo 拳闘 Boxen бокс มวย Boks 拳击 Box (@Hock1717)

Just been added...

[asgarth]

Alejandro Guerrero Vs Jose Angulo.

Close, but no issue with Guerrero winning.
He stunned and hurt Angulo in four different rounds, so those rounds are certainly scored for him, but Angulo outboxed him in three rounds. First round was close and could have gone either way.

77-75 for Guerrero or 76-76 Draw was possible.
Elijah Staples had it 79-73. Tim Taggert 78-74 (third judge had it a draw).

[_Rexy_]

Eli Staples 79-73

[TheMyspaceDayz]

Eli Staples 79-73

Angulo won 3 rounds so clearly that there is no way to give him fewer without cheating. Eli Staples is bought and paid for. Tim Taggert and Staples will probably be celebrating over the same glass of win.