If Manny were to fight and beat Spence would he outrank Floyd P4P?

[Street]

Since P4P only involves ranking active fighters, your question by default is a nonsense question. Floyd’s status is as that of Ali, Robinson, and all the greats who have hung the gloves.

[Robbie Barrett]

I often wonder if those Ring Annual Rankings need to be updated.

I can't say I recall but surely Judah can't have been in the P4P list after losing to Baldomir??!!!

I've noticed this kind of thing a few times.

Maybe you're right and they have the date wrong because they have Judah listed as the WW champion. Or the April issue was printed in December because the cover does say year end awards.

[Thraxox]

Floyd only outranks Manny on your side of the list. It isn't on everyone else.

[Robbie Barrett]

Floyd only outranks Manny on your side of the list. It isn't on everyone else.

Just stop it. Mayweather is regarded as the best of the era by almost everyone. Only the extremely biased rank Pacquiao higher, like you.

[Thraxox]

Just stop it. Mayweather is regarded as the best of the era by almost everyone. Only the extremely biased rank Pacquiao higher, like you.

Tell me that when Mayweather finally defeats a prime A level fighter. To which he never did in his entire career.

[Vasyl’s dad]

No. The head to head win is a bit more telling

So Tarver, Johnson, Calzaghe>>>Jones?

[Vasyl’s dad]

Guerrero on any pound for pound list is just incredibly ******. He was never ever one of the 10 best fighters in the world.

[Robbie Barrett]

Tell me that when Mayweather finally defeats a prime A level fighter. To which he never did in his entire career.

Mayweather defeated everyone. Most title holders, most P4P fighters in history. He's viewed as the best of the era, no amount of crying from Pacquiao fans is going to change that.

[hhs661]

So Tarver, Johnson, Calzaghe>>>Jones?

Sure man. I'm sure your smart enough to know EXACTLY what I meant but I'll go along with you

[Thraxox]

Mayweather defeated everyone. Most title holders, most P4P fighters in history. He's viewed as the best of the era, no amount of crying from his fans is going to change that.

When the likes of Broner and Guerrero are in the p4p lists and each weight class has 4 belts you know "Most P4P fighters and world titles" are B.S His resume is one of the most carefully managed creation ever, full of past it fighters whom their best days have have already passed years ago.

His best win is Canelo whom was 23 years old, and had to drain him so hard that he can't stand up at the weigh in and had to go 155 immediately in his next fight.

You think that Mayweather is the best of his era, cool, more power to you, but I don't share that nor does the rest of the world, a lot might share it also, but a lot doesn't share it also, that's why it's called opinions.