Is Kell Brook now an elite welterweight who can defeat the best?

[Beercules]

My baby mama

[El Malo.]

His making a name for himself, but his resume is still lacking and we are yet to see if his style matches well against other top fighters. Portman was a great win that put his name in the mix but still needs to put in work. . . . . . As much as I don't rate Khan that high I believe he beats Brooks quit easy

[Strategic1]

A part of me wants Floyd and PAC to school or put a beatdown on Brook, Thurman and Khan. Especially these undefeated fighters Brook and Thurman.

Just to show once again, that ATG level skill can overcome what these young guys bring. I'm not even that big of a Floyd fan but respect his skill.

I'd find it wildly entertaining for Floyd and PAC to take their 0's.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

A part of me wants Floyd and PAC to school or put a beatdown on Brook, Thurman and Khan. Especially these undefeated fighters Brook and Thurman.

Just to show once again, that ATG level skill can overcome what these young guys bring. I'm not even that big of a Floyd fan but respect his skill.

I'd find it wildly entertaining for Floyd and PAC to take their 0's.

At this stage, might backfire...

Hopkins didn't take jermain Taylor's 0

[12TRIBEsRiSe]

Co-sign!!!!

Only Elites in the WW division are fighting on May 2nd. All the rest are contenders, with some in the crowd trying to skate their way to the top.

true!!! there are good fighters and then there are elite fighters

[Strategic1]

At this stage, might backfire...

Hopkins didn't take jermain Taylor's 0

Of course it may backfire, that's what makes it intriguing/entertaining to me. Brook and Thurman have a shot of course.

I'd like to see both guys now face elite elite competition. Let's see how well they do.

[Brickyardigan]

The way Brook looked today...

He definitely a problem, he might have the goods BEAT MAYWEATHER. His right hand and set-ups are extraordinary, at least what he showed tonight. He is on that level. Keith Thurman, I don't know... Kell Brook might be the best in the division. However Jo Jo Dan may not have been a good barometer of skill and power... So everyone just take this comment as my "in the moment" assessment. Mayweather dominance of Pacquiao and my constant replays of Kell Brook recent showing will more than likely show Mayweather is still tiers above him.

[Box-Office]

Beating Shawn Porter and Jo Jo Dan makes you elite now?

Yeah, he is very good.

[Sugar Adam Ali]

Of course it may backfire, that's what makes it intriguing/entertaining to me. Brook and Thurman have a shot of course.

I'd like to see both guys now face elite elite competition. Let's see how well they do.

I agree, my favorite matchup in boxing is the unproven young gun vs the aging great veteran.. Always very intriguing to see those

[Strategic1]

Since most of the top 10 welters have fought recently, how'd you rate them.

1. Floyd
2. Pacquiao
3. Bradley...why? still has a better resume than the next few guys. And he did beat Chaves CLEARLY even with 1 eye.
4. Brook... beating Porter is slighty better than beating Guerrero.
5. Thurman... beating Guerrero shows he's legit. Time to step it up even more.
6. Khan.... beating Alexander is a solid win. But now he needs to forget floyd/pac for now and face the best possible opposition
7. Shawn Porter- Still young enough to learn from the Brook defeat.
8. Maidana 2 losses to Floyd. I dont think he can beat any of the opponents above.
9. Diego Chaves
10. Brandon Rios

Outside looking in...
JMM- hasn't done anything since KTFO6 so I took him out of my rankings.
Guerrero- Tough opponent but he's just ordinary at 147
Sadam Ali-
Devon Alexander-