Comments Thread For: Bradley Makes a Move: BScene Pound-for-Pound Update

[MDPopescu]

There are only four U.S. fighters in the BoxingScene P4P list... Fair enough... Broner's missing...

[Realizniguhnit]

The list lost all credibility with Carl Froch...

[hitking]

The list lost all credibility with Carl Froch...

Not as bad as Ring ****zine having Broner on their list, but still bad. Froch isn't a P4P fighter. But there's only lik maybe 5-6 guys out there I consider truly elite. So I guess you have to fill the list out with somebody.

[MDPopescu]

I don't know if Froch is a P4P top ten fighter. But I know that he deserves lots of respect.

[lillu89]

Replace froch with wladimir. and also replace Gonzalez with Juan Francisco Estrada then you have a list.

[WilkinsOlajuwon]

There are only four U.S. fighters in the BoxingScene P4P list... Fair enough... Broner's missing...

Broner should be missing

[hitking]

Broner should be missing

The P4P list is matter of opinion. Someone like myself bases a list more on accomplishments. Others base it more on who they think would win a fight in a weight indifferent world. For example, I think in a weight indifferent world, Rigondeaux is a better fighter that Floyd and would beat him head-2-head. But Floyd is higher on my list because he's more accomplished. Broner started popping up on lists when he completely dismantled what many thought was the best lightweight in the world Demarco. So even though Broner's resume isn't P4P worthy, some may feel in a weight indifferent world he's. One of the best 10 fighers in the world. P4P lists are very subjec and while fun to debate, a lotta stock shouldn't be put into them.

[Jhp]

Replace froch with wladimir. and also replace Gonzalez with Juan Francisco Estrada then you have a list.

Gonzalez beat Estrada less than a year ago.

[lutenco]

WARD is the " WBA SUPER CHAMPION" not FROCH c'mon,write right please;it's an insult put FROCH as "SUPER CHAMPION" and WARD as "REGULAR CHAMPION"!!!

[lillu89]

Gonzalez beat Estrada less than a year ago.

I know he did but Estrada went on to win the titles from viloria over in china. Then He defended the titles against Melindo. And I think viloria was a top 10 p4p fighter at the time Estrada beat him.