Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Jose Luis Castillo VS Floyd Mayweather I, Who really won??

Collapse
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    I dislike Mayweather now, but back then, I didn't. I knew he was good but had no ill feelings towards him and I was expecting him to win, but in my view, he didn't.

    Comment


      Originally posted by Beercules View Post
      Answer this question: did Floyd get outlanded by 100+ power punches by Castillo during the course of 12 rounds. Yes or no?
      Yes. But that in and of itself isn't valid.

      If floyd wins 7 rounds and Castillo wins 5, yet in those 5 rounds Castillo has such an enormous amount of activity that the final punch landed total is Castillo + 100, then he lost the fight. Period.

      You know this yet for some reason are stubbornly clinging to it to say floyd lost.

      What if in a round you are deducted a point yet landed more. Compubox doesn't register it being a 9-9 round, only the punches landed.

      Come on man, we can disagree on who won but at least be credible.

      Comment


        Originally posted by The Big Dunn View Post
        Yes. But that in and of itself isn't valid.

        If floyd wins 7 rounds and Castillo wins 5, yet in those 5 rounds Castillo has such an enormous amount of activity that the final punch landed total is Castillo + 100, then he lost the fight. Period.

        You know this yet for some reason are stubbornly clinging to it to say floyd lost.

        What if in a round you are deducted a point yet landed more. Compubox doesn't register it being a 9-9 round, only the punches landed.

        Come on man, we can disagree on who won but at least be credible.
        You are seeking to ignore the fact that Castillo outworked Floyd.

        Like I said, Floyd swept the 1-4 easily. Then Castillo took over the middle rounds and finished the fight later on.


        Castillo won the later rounds clearer than Floyd. Let's not forget that 10-8 round Floyd had for using his veteran tactic elbow.

        Comment


          this fight should have been a dq win for floyd. castillo wasn't even wearing pillow gloves like wtf. that's why so many people be dyin.

          Comment


            Does not matter. Floyd was nice enough to offer Castillio a rematch and ended all the fuss.

            But on boxing scene that is not enough

            Comment


              Originally posted by daggum View Post
              this fight should have been a dq win for floyd. castillo wasn't even wearing pillow gloves like wtf. that's why so many people be dyin.

              Comment


                Originally posted by rambov View Post
                Does not matter. Floyd was nice enough to offer Castillio a rematch and ended all the fuss.

                But on boxing scene that is not enough
                Why did he need a rematch if (his fans) think he won clearly?


                Same with Maidana. What happened?

                Comment


                  I bet most that voted haven't even seen the fight. Can't wait until they go into hiding after May 2nd.

                  Comment


                    Originally posted by Beercules View Post
                    Why did he need a rematch if (his fans) think he won clearly?


                    Same with Maidana. What happened?
                    why did

                    Manny need a rematch with Jmm,Morales,Bradley and Barrera??

                    Why did Ray leonard need a rematch with Duran and Hearns?

                    Why did Ray Robinson need rematches with several fighters??

                    Why did Ali need rematches??


                    do i need to keep going?

                    Comment


                      Originally posted by Beercules View Post
                      Why did he need a rematch if (his fans) think he won clearly?


                      Same with Maidana. What happened?
                      For every fan he has, he has 5 haters.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X
                      TOP