How is Pac still ranked P4P #1 on BS?

[bare knuckle]

By the time Floyd retired. Its been 5 years since then and up to this moment he only fought just 4 times. These were how he won those 4 fights.



In year 2012, he fought Cotto when obviously he should fought him 5 years early when he was young and in his prime but he faked his retirement instead to duck him.

In year 2011, he sucker puched the great Ortiz to ensure his victory. LMAO p4p worthy win in their opinion.

In year 2010, he fought Mosley when obviously he should fought him 3 years early when he was still young and in his prime but he faked his retirement instead to duck him.

In year 2009, he weight cheated Marquez and didn't try to make weight at all to ensure his victory. What joke a p4p win in their opinion.

Now in those the same 5 years, Pacquiao fought 12 times mostly all won by ko, tko or one sided beat down. 12 > 4 at the same 5 years span. How did you do the math?

in the last 5 years that includes 2007 floyd has fought nothing but CURRENT CHAMPIONS

Hatton-undefeated p4p top 10

Oscar-154 wbc champ

Jmm-p4p#2

Shane-p4p#3 wba champ #1 ww

Ortiz-wbc champ

Cotto-wba 154 champ


Manny since 2007 has fought


David diaz-135 wbc champ

Jmm-wbc 130 champ


Hatton-lineal champ 140

Oscar-no title

Cotto-wbo champ


AND THATS WHERE IT STOPS IN 2009


Clottey-coming off of a loss

Margo-coming off of a suspension and a loss

Shane-hadnt won in 2 years

Jmm-38 year old lightweight still p4p top 5-many thing manny loss

Bradley-undefeated 140 pound fighter offically beat mann tho most think he won




this isnt not even debatable son..Manny hasnt done jack**** since 2009

[whirlwind]

Floyd
Ward
Martinez
Donaire

should all be ranked over Manny

Floyd 2008-2012

past prime Cotto
sucker punched Ortiz
past prime Mosley
weight cheated Marquez

Pacquiao 2008-2012

Pac beat Bradley in one sided but got robbed
Pac beat Marquez fairly, no weight cheating, fight can go either way
past prime Mosley
17 lbs weight advantage Margarito
one sided decision prime Clottey
tko12 prime Cotto
tko Hatton in rd2 and retired him for good
made him quit and retired Oscar for good
Diaz
beat the younger prime Marquez in a close fight


How do you justify that?

[The Big Dunn]

Floyd 2008-2012

past prime Cotto
sucker punched Ortiz
past prime Mosley
weight cheated Marquez

Pacquiao 2008-2012

Pac beat Bradley in one sided but got robbed
Pac beat Marquez fairly, no weight cheating, fight can go either way
past prime Mosley
17 lbs weight advantage Margarito
one sided decision prime Clottey
tko12 prime Cotto
tko Hatton in rd2 and retired him for good
made him quit and retired Oscar for good
Diaz
beat the younger prime Marquez in a close fight


How do you justify that?

If the retirement was fake, as you say, then that means floyd should never have lost his spot atop the p4p rankings because he never really retired right? Inactivity is not a rreason to lose your spot.

On the other hand, if it was real, he came back and fought the #2 p4p fighter, JMM, and beat him more decisively than Manny had. I think any fighter that returns from retirement and beats the 2nd best fighter in the world earns the right to be #1.

SInce floyd has been atop the p4p rankings, manny has lost twice, once questionably, had a draw , and got what many say is a gift decision vs JMM.

That is a strong argument for floyd being #1.

[whirlwind]

in the last 5 years that includes 2007 floyd has fought nothing but CURRENT CHAMPIONS

Hatton-undefeated p4p top 10

Oscar-154 wbc champ

Jmm-p4p#2

Shane-p4p#3 wba champ #1 ww

Ortiz-wbc champ

Cotto-wba 154 champ


Manny since 2007 has fought


David diaz-135 wbc champ

Jmm-wbc 130 champ


Hatton-lineal champ 140

Oscar-no title

Cotto-wbo champ


AND THATS WHERE IT STOPS IN 2009


Clottey-coming off of a loss

Margo-coming off of a suspension and a loss

Shane-hadnt won in 2 years

Jmm-38 year old lightweight still p4p top 5-many thing manny loss

Bradley-undefeated 140 pound fighter offically beat mann tho most think he won




this isnt not even debatable son..Manny hasnt done jack**** since 2009

Floyd faked his retirement in 2008. Since then...

Floyd 2008-2012

past prime Cotto
sucker punched Ortiz
past prime Mosley
weight cheated Marquez

Pacquiao 2008-2012

Pac beat Bradley in one sided but got robbed
Pac beat Marquez fairly, no weight cheating, fight can go either way
past prime Mosley
17 lbs weight advantage Margarito
one sided decision prime Clottey
tko12 prime Cotto
tko Hatton in rd2 and retired him for good
made him quit and retired Oscar for good
Diaz
beat the younger prime Marquez in a close fight

[bare knuckle]

Floyd 2008-2012

past prime Cotto
sucker punched Ortiz
past prime Mosley
weight cheated Marquez

Pacquiao 2008-2012

Pac beat Bradley in one sided but got robbed
Pac beat Marquez fairly, no weight cheating, fight can go either way
past prime Mosley
17 lbs weight advantage Margarito
one sided decision prime Clottey
tko12 prime Cotto
tko Hatton in rd2 and retired him for good
made him quit and retired Oscar for good
Diaz
beat the younger prime Marquez in a close fight


How do you justify that?

In 2012 Floyd went up to 154(not 150)and beat the #1 jww for the wba title

In 2012 Manny lost to a JWW

END THREAD

[bare knuckle]

Why does this guy keep posting the same thing over and over and keep getting owned over and over?

[whirlwind]

Why does this guy keep posting the same thing over and over and keep getting owned over and over?

Because you are ****** and can't comprehend simple things.

[whirlwind]

In 2012 Floyd went up to 154(not 150)and beat the #1 jww for the wba title - that was 5 years later when Cotto already past his prime.

In 2012 Manny lost to a JWW - read my sig.

END THREAD

Fixed for you.

[Xyei]

Pacquiao took Marquez lightly? Yeah, right. He took a guy lightly who he already had 2 really tough fights with? :jerk: What a lame excuse.

Anyway, P4P rankings are hypothetical anyway. It's not like it really means much.

[The Big Dunn]

Fixed for you.

If the retirement was fake, as you say, then that means floyd should never have lost his spot atop the p4p rankings because he never really retired right? Inactivity is not a rreason to lose your spot.

On the other hand, if it was real, he came back and fought the #2 p4p fighter, JMM, and beat him more decisively than Manny had. I think any fighter that returns from retirement and beats the 2nd best fighter in the world earns the right to be #1.

SInce floyd has been atop the p4p rankings, manny has lost twice, once questionably, had a draw , and got what many say is a gift decision vs JMM.

That is a strong argument for floyd being #1.