Which win is more impressive, Mayweather vs Corrales or Pacquiao vs Barrera 1?

[$tate of Mind]

I can't decide- they're both their greatest wins.

Barrera is a solid top 30 ATG though and Corralles isn't.

But the way Mayweather beat him was spectacular.

This is a good post. Barrera is superior to Corrales, but Mayweather's performance was jaw dropping. You can't go wrong either way.

[LeG00N]

it's not even debatable... unless you're extremely biased towards Floyd

[FilMor]

Corrales is a club fighter compared to a prime Barrera, also Corrales was weight drained I believe he had to lose an absurd amount of weight in a few weeks, like 40+ pounds.

[$coinblatt$]

taking the FW Lineal title away from an ATG like Barrera is much greater then beating Corrales.

[Roy Hobbs]

Barerra win is far more impressive imo. Barerra is a bona fide legitimate ATG hall of famer who was no less top 3 p4p in the entire sport only behind roy jones and floyd when manny dominated him. Barerra was on a 8 fight winning streak before he lost to manny and went on a 6 fight winning streak after he lost to manny only losing to another bona fide ATG in marquez whome he dropped in the fight.

Corrales was a solid champion but not really hall of fame material.

[Body_Snatcher]

More impressed with Mayweather beating Corrales. Heck I think Mayweather's SR even didn't want his son to fight Corrales.

[Jcsuper]

Floyd lovers are going to say the win against Corrales

Floyd haters are going to say the win against Barrera

100 pages...


yawwwwwwnnnnnnn

[Frank Ducketts]

Floyd Chico without question. Chico was prime and ranked pfp. Barrera I think was still pfp, but he was past it, and didn't really give it his all.

[Frank Ducketts]

Barrera is a h.o.f fighter. He is not an atg.

[Jcsuper]

even if one is not a fan of the two, i think they would still say it's pac-barrera.

You're a floyd hater, so you fall in the second group, you'll say the win against Barrera.


yaaaaawnnnnnnnnnn