Fighter of the Year... Manny or Sergio?

[El Chicano]

Who takes it? #1 P4P vs #2 P4P... MAKE IT HAPPEN!

[mushahadeen]

Pac dominated Clottey and Margarito.

Serg beat Pavlik and KTFO the #3 P4P fighter of the year in 2.

Close but I would give it to Serg.

[mushahadeen]

Pac dominated Clottey and Margarito.

Serg beat Pavlik and KTFO the #3 P4P fighter of the year in 2.

Close but I would give it to Serg.

[Eric Holder]

Cochulito f.o.t.y

[Phil Ivey]

Clottey was an OK win, Margarito is a joke, no where near an elite fighter anymore. Martinez schooled Martinez and KO'd a p4p fighter. Martinez and its not even close.

EDIT: I MEAN SCHOOLED PAVLIK LOL

[El Chicano]

Clottey was an OK win, Margarito is a joke, no where near an elite fighter anymore. Martinez schooled Martinez and KO'd a p4p fighter. Martinez and its not even close.

That's what I'm saying, these two need to get it on.

[[ DUBBZZ ]]

Pac fan here...gotta give it to Sergio. He's the man this year.

[S H A R K B O Y]

Sergio Martinez. All of his opponents were formidable, especially Williams. Pacquiao fights anyone that moves as fast as a snail, Martinez has fought everyone who has let him fight them.

[BoZz]

sergio easy......

[ModernTalking]

Clottey was an OK win, Margarito is a joke, no where near an elite fighter anymore. Martinez schooled Martinez and KO'd a p4p fighter. Martinez and its not even close.

PAC will and should win fighter of the year because Martinez schooled Martinez. You can't not be fighter of the year if you schooled yourself.