Fighter of the Year... Manny or Sergio?

[paulf]

Clearly Martinez.

Now to avenge his only other loss....

[Madvillain]

Gotta say Martinez.

[Kevin Malone]

Sergio based on level of competition. Not even close really.

[Coyotefury]

Martinez should win, but its prolly gonna be given to manny

[Easy-E]

Martinez, and easily. Pavlik and Williams?

Or Clottey coming off a loss or Margarito who...got brutally knocked out, kicked out of boxing for a year and fought a nobody.

Not even close.

[sNiTcH]

Pac vs Sergio will be a good match up

Sergio was explosive... give him a props

[Crazylegs77]

[El Chicano]

Clearly Martinez.

Now to avenge his only other loss....

That would be great, but I don't know if that fight would sell anymore... Maybe on HBO in a lead up to a Manny Pacquiao showdown.

[El Chicano]

Pac vs Sergio will be a good match up

Sergio was explosive... give him a props

All props in the world to Sergio... He was patient, let Pwill get comfortable making mistakes, then made him PAY. Very smart fight by ***y tonight. He's clearly the #2 P4P fighter right now.

[Gino Ros]

Pac dominated Clottey and Margarito.

Serg beat Pavlik and KTFO the #3 P4P fighter of the year in 2.

Close but I would give it to Serg.

Pac decisioned two journeymen coming off losses/KO's.

Sergio dominated a bigger man with no catchweight. And then KO'd a guy who had never been KO'd.

Sergio by miles.