Doug Fischer: "Whitaker & JCC are the best of the last two decades, NOT Floyd & Pac"

[hugh grant]

Pernell maybe better than PBF but not Pac. Damn it, PBF is bringing Pacs name down and through the gutter, by trying to associate with Pac and his league.

[T.McGrady]

RJJ out of the conversation?!

[Frank Martin]

JCC and Sweet Pea fought the best oppositions out there....

[REDRUM619]

Pernell maybe better than PBF but not Pac. Damn it, PBF is bringing Pacs name down and through the gutter, by trying to associate with Pac and his league.

pernell better than pac floyd might be better than sweetpeo though

[paulf]

This shouldnt even be close. Sweet Pea and JCC.

[DUnknown1]

I can't believe some people think pac has a chance with sweet pea. People often confuse the similarities between the two of them.

First Pac and Whitaker both are fast, very fast. However to say that pac would knock out whitaker is complete bollocks.
Pea was a great defensive boxer, who would give angles and would counter constantly just look at what he did to chavez.
Just because Pac is as fast as Pea necessarily mean that it would be enough to knock out Pea.
Chavez was a monster, one of the hardest puncher in the LWW division, yet he couldn't touch Whitaker. Style's make fights, and I believe Pac would be missing all night.

Now Chavez vs. Pac that would've been a war both were hard hitting punchers, of course Pac being the faster one, while Chavez would try to slow him down with his awesome body punching. That fight would be a tossup, since I haven't seen anybody that can hit Pac's body lately. With Pac speed slowing down due to the body punching they would be killing each other to see who was the stronger puncher. But again it is a toss up.

Oh yeah and Pea and JCC are >>> Pac and Floyd (because they didn't duck and didn't impose catchweights) jk chill the *** out *******s and *****s

[DUnknown1]

Although RJJ was a monster I believe he wasn't mentioned due to the lack on longevity compared to JCC and Pea.

[Silencers]

All 4 are up there but if there were a top 2 I'd pick Whitaker and Pacquiao.

[JOM'S]

imho although not by much, P4P speaking Pac and PBF are better than pernell and chavez,
people are forgetting how far PAC has evolved ....

[cooper5]

In a way it is unfair to team Manny with Floyd in this rating. I think Chavez and Whitaker are more accomplished than Mayweather. Pacquiao is up there with them. Why not just do it as individual fighters.