Comments Thread For: Mayweather is Back: BScene’s Pound for Pound Top Ten

[jbpanama]

Nice article...Does chooosing opponents
that are UNDERSIZED and OVER the HILL
FACTOR into your selections....???

does a PUG who wants to change the RULES
set by the NAC IMPRESS U???

BOY's sudden CRUSADE to CLEAN UP BOXING,
when faced by Pac who clearly OUT CLASSES HIM
Give U pause!!!

Does testing AFTER the FIGHT make sense to U???

Were U well compensated for the LUDICRUS ADJUSTMENT
to YOUR MYTHICAL LIST??? I hope so as your credability
is in the TOILET alomg with BOY's continuing to PUNK OUT!!!


INFLUENCE your choices???

[damned1974]

Yeah, that's what's up..Number uno again..

lol peyk peyk and passthegassatyo are gonna be crying!

[ThePunchingBag]

They're pretty much 1a and 1b. Pac is only #2 because ppl are still buzzed from last weekends fight. Otherwise it's hard to argue for one or the other.

I agree with the rest of the list though.

[crold1]

I can't take this list seriously if they seriously have Mosley dropping out of the top 20.

It didn't nor does it say that...there are five other guys noted who a top ten case could be made for now. There really is no Mosley top ten case at the moment. The other five (Gamboa etc.) are mostly the rising star types still a win or three away from consideration.

[ROID RAGE 01]

Now Ronnie cant mention P4P and Manny in one sentence without Floyd.

[EDOMITESLAYER]

Marquez got dropped to low and is being penalized for losing to someone who cheated him on the scales and for fighting way out of his element.


Paul Williams lost to Martinez in most eyes and he's #3?

Awful list.

Thats because floyd didnt cheat he offered MARQUEZ THE ABILITY TO GO ahead with the fight and MARQUEZ a true warrior said **** it I am game.

Floyd didnt sneak in the damn ring and try and act like he was not two pounds over he told marquez.....

AND LETS NOT FOR GET THAT PACMAN CAME IN OVER THE WELTER WEIGHT LIMIT IN HIS CLOTTEY FIGHT, AS WELLAS CLOTTEY, I dont remember seeing anyone ask for 10,000,000 a pound, DID YOU?? Pac weighd in at 150. that would have been 30 million! lol!

[Khalid X]

Honestly I disagree because

Pac win Hatton> Mayweather's win over Hatton
Pac win over Cotto = Floyds win over Shane
Pac win over Clottey > Floyd's win over Marquez

To me that is how you gotta look at it. While his win over Shane was very impressive, so was Pac's win over Cotto. Both equally dominating but I felt the swing came win Pac beat Clottey who is considered a top 5 WW at the time. To me that is more impressive than a win over Marquez at WW and on top of that Pac destroyed Hatton in a more dominating fashion

Still if they put Floyd at #1 cool...won't argue....the above passage is just my view on things. Cong**** PBF and Floyd fans...no hate etc.

[etlux]

I'll be honest, in reality they're tied. Floyd and Pac are both p4p #1 right now but I know most organizations/institutions/sites don't allow ties like that so if I HAD to pick for now I'd choose Floyd #1 and if Pac were to beat someone decent a few months down the line I'd have no problem moving Pac back up to #1 but for now Floyd is definitely #1 and when they fight (IF they fight) that will settle it once and for all.

[Thickback]

I coulnd't agree more. Floyd's skill level is far above Pacman's "IMO"

[M.I.C.]

Pac can still get #1 back, all he has to do is beat Mosley next and say he beat him better than Mayweather did, that is afterall how he became #1 in the first place, Mayweather left overs