P4P #1 Re-Vote

[araindon]

It's dead even. They're both light years ahead of everyone else on the P4P list. So I'd say they're both No1 until they fight each other. It's too close for me to call.

[SkilledB]

Manny Pacquiao is definitely still #1.

Floyd decisioned an obviously very faded Shane Mosley.

And pac beat a faded cotto?

dude u can make the argument both ways, theres no way of knowing what kinda mosely would of showed up, floyd gets all the praise in the world for beating the man who took down Marg and nearly beat cotto in cotto's prime and comming off margs biggest win

[Russian Crushin]

It's dead even. They're both light years ahead of everyone else on the P4P list. So I'd say they're both No1 until they fight each other. It's too close for me to call.

Yup well said....the only way for the top 2 spots to swich is if they either fought eachohter for #1 or if one of them lost, otherwise they remain in place

[Doctor_Tenma]

Let me be real.

If Pacquiao was willing to take the blood test, I'd say Pacquiao was the number 1 P4P. Some may say that has nothing to do with the poll, but it does. In my opinion it does. And I'm 100% sure others are voting for Floyd simply because of that. .

[jimmykaba]

either 1 of them is acceptable their last fight wasnt really that amazing

[Russian Crushin]

And pac beat a faded cotto?

dude u can make the argument both ways, theres no way of knowing what kinda mosely would of showed up, floyd gets all the praise in the world for beating the man who took down Marg and nearly beat cotto in cotto's prime and comming off margs biggest win

Who says Mosley wasnt faded saturday? he sure looked it to me.....and cotto didnt look faded at all in the fight to pac

[araindon]

Yup well said....the only way for the top 2 spots to swich is if they either fought eachohter for #1 or if one of them lost, otherwise they remain in place

Yeah! The other thing is that when each fighter has a fight, the neutral is swung to that fighter. When Pacquiao beat Hatton, everyone said "no chance Floyd beats this animal". When Floyd beat JMM, everyone said "Money beat the man who gave Pacquaio hell...Floyd is the best". Then Manny beats down Cotto and everyone says "No one can beat Manny, he just demolished the man Floyd ducked"....then he beats Clottey and everyone is like "He won every round against a guy who does not engage and is defensive, Floyd has no hope" and THEN Floyd schools Mosley....and we have this aftermath buzz. Floyd is not Hatton, Cotto or Clottey....and Pacquiao is not JMM or Mosley.....lets wait and see what happens when they fight....I'd leave the rankings the same because they've not fought and both accomplished a lot in last year and a half....but to me they both the best of the best by miles.

[Russian Crushin]

Yeah! The other thing is that when each fighter has a fight, the neutral is swung to that fighter. When Pacquiao beat Hatton, everyone said "no chance Floyd beats this animal". When Floyd beat JMM, everyone said "Money beat the man who gave Pacquaio hell...Floyd is the best". Then Manny beats down Cotto and everyone says "No one can beat Manny, he just demolished the man Floyd ducked"....then he beats Clottey and everyone is like "He won every round against a guy who does not engage and is defensive, Floyd has no hope" and THEN Floyd schools Mosley....and we have this aftermath buzz. Floyd is not Hatton, Cotto or Clottey....and Pacquiao is not JMM or Mosley.....lets wait and see what happens when they fight....I'd leave the rankings the same because they've not fought and both accomplished a lot in last year and a half....but to me they both the best of the best by miles.

Yup and im sure that if you took this poll right after the Cotto fight, then the bigger chunk would be in Pacs favor......people are taking this one fight at a time instead of looking at the whole picture

[flexxx145]

Floyd "The Dragon" Mayweather Jr. has won the hearts and minds of the public. This poll on ******* heavy Boxingscene forums proves that.

[Russian Crushin]

Floyd "The Dragon" Mayweather Jr. has won the hearts and minds of the public. This poll on ******* heavy Boxingscene forums proves that.

lmao "the dragon"? Floyd should have way more fans here on BS because he is american and this site is majority american

Im honestly amazed how Manny has transfered over to the US.

and get off all this BS that he won our heart and minds becaue otherwise you would be chanting "Floyd, Floyd" instead of "mosley, Mosley" in Floyd home town of Las Vegas