Is Joe Calzaghe an all-time great?

[Royalty]

He's generally regarded as the greatest super middleweight of all-time, but some people don't think he's an all-time great.

What do you think?

[B.U.R.N.E.R]

He's generally regarded as the greatest super middleweight of all-time, but some people don't think he's an all-time great.

What do you think?

Considering the 168 Pound weight class has only been around since 1989 thats not a good feat. That divison best fighters ever are Benn, Jones Jr, Ottke, etc...


Hes not an ATG.

[Pullcounter]

He's generally regarded as the greatest super middleweight of all-time, but some people don't think he's an all-time great.

What do you think?

maybe in the UK... no where else

[krispy kreme]

He was a good fighter, but no ATG.

[AKATheMack]

Im confused on how to judge ATG. Are there different levels of ATG? He's definitely not an ALI, SRL type of an ATG thats for sure sure.

[ma51f]

yes, no doubt.

he was a great boxer and id still pick him to beat the winner of the super 6

[General Zod]

Considering the 168 Pound weight class has only been around since 1989 thats not a good feat. That divison best fighters ever are Benn, Jones Jr, Ottke, etc...


Hes not an ATG.

lmao. He is more accomplished than all those guys at smw.

[Royalty]

Im confused on how to judge ATG. Are there different levels of ATG? He's definitely not an ALI, SRL type of an ATG thats for sure sure.

I think a good limit to judge whether a fighter is an all-time great would be the top 50. It's up to you, though.

[General Zod]

maybe in the UK... no where else

Who would you rank higher and why?

[boxasmash]

Yes, he's an ATG.