Is Joe Calzaghe an all-time great?

[S H O B O X]

He was a good fighter, but no ATG.

give me 100 k , i read your secret message!

[krispy kreme]

give me 100 k , i read your secret message!

About time

[IMDAZED]

Standards must be dropping.

[Derranged]

He should be crowned the Prince Of Wales.

[Lakas]

I'd beleive he is.

[General Zod]

Standards must be dropping.

lol

If I had time to make a ATG list he would be around position 100-120

[Shazam!]

Cleaning out your division and going unbeaten as champion for over ten years? Beating Top 10 P4P'ers like Mikkel Kessler (At the time) and Bernard Hopkins?

Yeah, I think that makes you an all-time great.

[IMDAZED]

Cleaning out your division and going unbeaten as champion for over ten years? Beating Top 10 P4P'ers like Mikkel Kessler (At the time) and Bernard Hopkins?

Yeah, I think that makes you an all-time great.

Kessler was never top ten.

[Royalty]

Kessler was never top ten.

True, but it was still a great win.

[General Zod]

Kessler was never top ten.

What about Davisd Starie?