HORUS PRESENTS: Who wins more Legit: DLH vs.JCC or PAC v. MAB,EM ??

[El Castigador]

so if floyd beats pacquiao, he shouldn't get any credit because pac has been in a lot of wars?

i know what your answer will be, so just try explaining it

Did you read the part in my post where I said its Pacs best win to date?

[Khalid X]

The reasons people dont know how good junior jones was is because they were not watching back then and dont check out older fights.

They know who mab is because that fight was the one that jump started pac career. but since pac beat mab and mab lost to junior jones twice that must mean junior jones was a bad loss for marco.

the more I see these threads, the more I see that pac fans are more knowledgable than Floyd fans.

I love how that worked out especially after all the beating of their chest about us being only fans of pac and not fans of the sport.

[El Castigador]

Well then explain it to me cuz I am having trouble at what was Horus point with all this...

I cant speak for him but I think hes implying that MAB and Morales werent at their peak when Pac fought them. I think hes using the fact that MAB was in some very violent fights before Pac fought him. Thats all I can think of.

[El Castigador]

the more I see these threads, the more I see that pac fans are more knowledgable than Floyd fans.

I love how that worked out especially after all the beating of their chest about us being only fans of pac and not fans of the sport.

There are some fans of Floyd who have knowledge and there are some fans of Pac who have knowledge. Its pretty damn rare though.

[jrosales13]

b-b-b-ut I thought Floyd fans are fans of boxing and Pac fans are only fans of certain fighters.

Apparently they was not watching the lower weight-classes to know that Junior Jones was a good fighter... A top 10 fighter... So is no shame in loosing to him... And, there was no beating... in the fight where got Barrera got DQ'd I wouldn't considered a beating...

[LeeVanCleef]

Had DLH - FMJr. II was made, this poll would have been more interesting. It will give some balance, since it's about DLH - PAC against HOF at their respective weight classes. Just a thought.

[jrosales13]

I cant speak for him but I think hes implying that MAB and Morales werent at their peak when Pac fought them. I think hes using the fact that MAB was in some very violent fights before Pac fought him. Thats all I can think of.

OK... but, when was Barrera peak? If Barrera was not in his peak in the first fight. Then when exactly was his peak? I am just asking cuz after a couple violent fights against Morales he looked pretty damn good against a top 5 Johnny Tapia where Barrera won quite easily... And, Barrera also stopped a past prime Kevin Kelly who was coming off a win over Humberto Soto... And, then fought Pac... And, after Pac still beat Morales, Ayala, Peden who beat Nate Campbell 2x, and Juarez 2x... So if that was not Barrera peak when exactly was it?

[fdotorres]

Did you read the part in my post where I said its Pacs best win to date?

exactly, you tried to criticize what you called pac's greatest achievement

"barrera went through a lot of wars". **** sherlock, so have most of the best boxers active at the moment. that shouldn't stop anyone for giving some fighter credit if he were to beat cotto, margarito, mosley, pacquiao, hatton, marquez, diaz, williams, martinez, pavlik, etc

[Khalid X]

There are some fans of Floyd who have knowledge and there are some fans of Pac who have knowledge. Its pretty damn rare though.

to be fair I always looked at it like this: There are some fans of Floyd that are knowledgable and Same with pac fans. On the other hand there are some bad pac fans but there is an equal amount of bad Floyd fans

BUt no...it's Pac fans who have knowledge is not a rarity....no more rare than floyd fans with knowledge

[El Castigador]

OK... but, when was Barrera peak? If Barrera was not in his peak in the first fight. Then when exactly was his peak?

He was P4P Number 3 when Pac fought him can't argue that.