Who ranks higher all time RJJ, Hopkins or Calzaghe?

[123tyson123]

imo

1. Roy Jones Jr
2. Bernard Hopkins
.
.
.
.
.
3. Joe Calzaghe

I rate Hopkins higher than Jones and Calzaghe. I think if Jones had retired after the ruiz fight I would probably have him number 1 out of the 3. Hopkins at 44-45 is still a p4p fighter and in my opinion the greatest over 40s fighter in history. Even though calzaghe has a win over him it was clearly a huge struggle and unconvincing. And this was a old hopkins remember. I beileve if calzaghe had fought hopkins ( and jones ) when they where peaked he wouldnt have stood a chance.

1. Hopkins
2. Jones
3. Calzaghe

[Hyde]

I rate Hopkins higher than Jones and Calzaghe. I think if Jones had retired after the ruiz fight I would probably have him number 1 out of the 3. Hopkins at 44-45 is still a p4p fighter and in my opinion the greatest over 40s fighter in history. Even though calzaghe has a win over him it was clearly a huge struggle and unconvincing. And this was a old hopkins remember. I beileve if calzaghe had fought hopkins ( and jones ) when they where peaked he wouldnt have stood a chance.

1. Hopkins
2. Jones
3. Calzaghe

Good post. Hopkins and RJJ are really close imo but Slapzaghe falls far behind them in the atg rankings.

Calzaghe is no better than Zsolt Erdei or Sven Ottke.

[S A M U R A I]

Roy Jones Jr. ranks higher all time.



| |

[123tyson123]

No, Calzaghe beat Hopkins. End of.

Hopkins is also not actually that past prime. What a lot of people (idiots - such as yourself) don't realise is that Calzaghe was actually further removed from his prime. You could see Calzaghe's speed, work rate and endurance was not as good as during his prime years (around 30). Hopkins on the other hand, while past prime was actually not far removed from it at all - as proved by the Pavlik demolition.

Hopkin's resume is garbage. He has about 2 good wins - against Tarver and Trinidad. The rest are just big names - they weren't good fighters where Hopkins fought them.

Hopkins resume is garbage? Tarver and Trinidad are the only 2 good names?

[>Lord13<]

Easily Calzaghe.
He beat them both, and never lost.

[VipersThunder]

imo

1. Roy Jones Jr
2. Bernard Hopkins
.
.
.
.
.
3. Joe Calzaghe

Calzaghe's not even in the discussion. He's just another Euro joke. Everyone knows that.

[GoogleMe]

1. roy jones
2. hopkins
3. calzaghe

Easy one. Cazlaghe is a great figther, faced a few good ones, but nothing more. Roy and Hopkins have fought many great fights within and out of their respective weightclass'

[Hyde]

Easily Calzaghe.
He beat them both, and never lost.

lmfao he beat a shot 40 year old roy jones jr and a past prime 44 year old hopkins.

being undeafeted means NOTHING when you have a **** resume like slapzaghe.

i guess Zsolt Erdei and Sven Ottke are all time greats aswell? LMFAO.

[GoogleMe]

Calzaghe's not even in the discussion. He's just another Euro joke. Everyone knows that.

Stop that Euro joke thing.. Guess you're jealous of our economy or something..

[Hyde]

Calzaghe's not even in the discussion. He's just another Euro joke. Everyone knows that.

hold on now, not all european fighters are jokes but otherwise i agree, calzaghe doesn't belong with atg's like rjj and b-hop.

Calzaghe was no better than Zsolt Erdei and Sven Ottke.