Did Castillo beat Mayweather the first time?

[The_Demon]

i think castillo won but is was a close fight and floyd beat him soundly in the rematch so it really doesnt bother me

[blaze778]

Castillo should have, would have, could have won, but the bottom line is that the judges gave it to Mayweather in a fight that could have gone either way. Just like the two Pac-Marquez fights, Cotto-Clottey, etc., people just need to get over it especially in fights that are so close. There are some real blatant robberies like Trinidad-De la Hoya, Mosley-De la Hoya 2 or even Diaz-Malinaggi. But the bottom line is that fans love to debate decisions when it comes to their favorite fighters, but a decision is pretty much written in stone.

[MANGLER]

Get off this ****.

[BEEHOP]

Castillo did not beat Mayweather. EVER.

[-EX-]

Castillo didn't beat Floyd...

[Shadow boxer 3]

it could hav went either way but JLC was the champ so i giv him the benefit of the doubt. but floyd gav him a rematch and beat more convincingly

[baracuda]

yes unofficially...

[Hopkiller]

The one thing that people bring up in any fight, are the punch stats and the *****S have always used the punch stats to confirm or strengthen their argument but when you ask them about the punch stats for the Castillo fight, they claim the compubox was broken But they brought up the compubox numbers once again to defend Floyd after the ODLH fight.

I say Floyd lost and so do many and I do mean many other people.

I hate those who use the punch stats as a valid point. Sometimes it counts and sometimes it doesn't.

Whats the point of a fighter touching his opponent just to score points, but not putting any hurt on him? I much rather check the power punches stats those punches come with a real purpose than those shots used just to score. Remember when fighters like Hopkins clinch then tag there rival a couple of times just so the punches can be added for the final compubox stats. They do no harm just annoy his opponent from the ******ity.

[Sin City]

they've done countless polls on this site and many other sites and the decision is unanimous: the majority of fans believe castillo won, and when I say majority I mean like 75%

[The Gambler1981]

they've done countless polls on this site and many other sites and the decision is unanimous: the majority of fans believe castillo won, and when I say majority I mean like 75%

Pull up one of those polls they all range from 60-65%, most fans also can not score for ****.

You argued that Froch-Dirrell was a close fight that could go either way, this fight is much closer then that fight because it was back and forth.

So which is it.